5. We believe, say they, in the resurrection of the
body. This confession, if only it be sincere, is free from objection.
But as there are bodies celestial and bodies terrestrial 1 Cor. xv. 40. and as thin air and the æther are
both according to their natures called bodies, they use the word body
instead of the word flesh in order that an orthodox person hearing them
say body may take them to mean flesh while a heretic will understand
that they mean spirit. This is their first piece of craft, and if this
is found out, they devise fresh wiles, and, pretending innocence
themselves, accuse us of malice. As though they were frank believers
they say, “We believe in the resurrection of the flesh.”
Now when they have said this, the ignorant crowd thinks it ought to be
satisfied, particularly because these exact words are found in the
creed. Article XI. of the
Apostles’ Creed speaks in the original forms of the resurrection
not of “the body” but of “the flesh:” and it is
still found in this shape in the Anglican office for the visitation of
the sick. If you go on to question them
farther, a buzz of disapproval is heard in the ring and their backers
cry out: “You have heard them say that they believe in the
resurrection of the flesh; what more do you want?” the popular
favour is transferred from our side to theirs, and while they are
called honest, we are looked on as false accusers. But if you set your
face steadily and keeping a firm hold of their admission about the
flesh, proceed to press them as to whether they assert the resurrection
of that flesh which is visible and tangible, which walks and speaks,
they first laugh and then signify their assent. And when we inquire
whether the resurrection will exhibit anew the hair and the teeth, the
chest and the stomach, the hands and the feet, and all the other
members of the body, then no longer able to contain their mirth they
burst out laughing and tell us that in that case we shall need barbers,
and cakes, and doctors, and cobblers. Do we, they ask us in turn,
believe that after the resurrection men’s cheeks will still be
rough and those of women smooth, and that sex will differentiate their
bodies as it does at present? Then if we admit this, they at once
deduce from our admission conclusions involving the grossest
materialism. Thus, while they maintain the resurrection of the body as
a whole, they deny the resurrection of its separate members.