45. Thus the Bishop. If then any one finds fault
with those who met at Nicæa, as if they contradicted the decisions
of their predecessors, he might reasonably find fault also with the
seventy, because they did not keep to the statements of their own
predecessors; but such were the Dionysii and the Bishops assembled on
that occasion at Rome. But neither these nor those is it pious to
blame; for all were charged with the embassy of Christ, and all have
given diligence against the heretics, and the one party condemned the
Samosatene, while the other condemned the Arian heresy. And rightly
have both these and those written, and suitably to the matter in hand.
And as the blessed Apostle, writing to the Romans, said, ‘The Law
is spiritual, the Law is holy, and the commandment holy and just and
good’ (Rom. vii. 14,
12); and soon after,
‘What the Law could not do, in that it was weak’ (ib.
viii. 3), but wrote to the
Hebrews, ‘The Law has made no one perfect’ (Heb. vii. 19); and to the Galatians, ‘By the
Law no one is justified’ (Gal. iii. 11), but to Timothy, ‘The Law is
good, if a man use it lawfully’ (1 Tim. i. 8); and no one would accuse the Saint of
inconsistency and variation in writing, but rather would admire how
suitably he wrote to each, to teach the Romans and the others to turn
from the letter to the spirit, but to instruct the Hebrews and
Galatians to place their hopes, not in the Law, but in the Lord who had
given the Law;—so, if the Fathers of the two Councils made
different mention of the Coessential, we ought not in any respect to
differ from them, but to investigate their meaning, and this will fully
show us the agreement of both the
Councils. For they who deposed the Samosatene took Coessential in a
bodily sense, because Paul had attempted sophistry and said,
‘Unless Christ has of man become God, it follows that He is
Coessential with the Father; and if so, of necessity there are three
essences, one the previous essence, and the other two from it;’
and therefore guarding against this they said with good reason, that
Christ was not Coessential This
is in fact the objection which Arius urges against the Coessential,
supr. §16, when he calls it the doctrine of Manichæus
and Hieracas, vid. §16, note 11. The same objection is protested
against by S. Basil, contr. Eunom. i. 19. Hilar. de Trin.
iv. 4. Yet, while S. Basil agrees with Athan. in his account of the
reason of the Council’s rejection of the word, S. Hilary on the
contrary reports that Paul himself accepted it, i.e. in a Sabellian
sense, and therefore the Council rejected it. ‘Male
homoüsion Samosatenus confessus est, sed numquid melius Arii
negaverunt.’ de Syn. 86.. For the Son is not
related to the Father as he imagined. But the Bishops who anathematized
the Arian heresy, understanding Paul’s craft, and reflecting that
the word ‘Coessential’ has not this meaning when used of
things immaterial Cf.
Soz. iii. 18. The heretical party, starting with the notion in which
their heresy in all its shades consisted, that the Son was a distinct
being from the Father, concluded that ‘like in
essence’ was the only term which would express the relation of
the Son to the Father. Here then the word ‘coessential’ did
just enable the Catholics to join issue with them, as exactly
expressing what the Catholics wished to express, viz. that there was no
such distinction between Them as made the term ‘like’
necessary, but that as material parent and offspring are individuals
under one common species, so the Eternal Father and Son are
Persons under one common individual essence., and especially of
God, and acknowledging that the Word was not a creature, but an
offspring from the essence, and that the Father’s essence was the
origin and root and fountain of the Son, and that he was of very truth
His Father’s likeness, and not of different nature, as we are,
and separate from the Father, but that, as being from Him, He exists as
Son indivisible, as radiance is with respect to Light, and knowing too
the illustrations used in Dionysius’s case, the
‘fountain,’ and the defence of ‘Coessential’
and before this the Saviour’s saying, symbolical of unity §49., ‘I and the Father are one’ and
‘he that hath seen Me hath seen the Father’ (John x. 30; xiv. 9), on these grounds reasonably asserted
on their part, that the Son was Coessential. And as, according to a
former remark, no one would blame the Apostle, if he wrote to the
Romans about the Law in one way, and to the Hebrews in another; in like
manner, neither would the present Bishops find fault with the ancient,
having regard to their interpretation, nor again in view of theirs and
of the need of their so writing about the Lord, would the ancient
censure their successors. Yes surely, each Council has a sufficient
reason for its own language; for since the Samosatene held that the Son
was not before Mary, but received from her the origin of His being,
therefore those who then met deposed him and pronounced him heretic;
but concerning the Son’s Godhead writing in simplicity, they
arrived not at accuracy concerning the Coessential, but, as they
understood the word, so spoke they about it. For they directed all
their thoughts to destroy the device of the Samosatene, and to shew
that the Son was before all things, and that, instead of becoming God
from man, He, being God, had put on a servant’s form, and being
Word, had become flesh, as John says (Phil. ii. 7; Joh. i. 14). This is how they dealt with the
blasphemies of Paul; but when Eusebius, Arius, and their fellows said
that though the Son was before time, yet was He made and one of the
creatures, and as to the phrase ‘from God,’ they did not
believe it in the sense of His being genuine Son from Father, but
maintained it as it is said of the creatures, and as to the oneness τὴν τῆς
ὁμοιώσεως
ἑνότητα:
and so pp. 163, note 9, 165, 166. And Basil. ταὐτότητα
τῆς φύσεως, Ep. 8. 3: [but] ταὐτότητα
τῆς οὐσιάς, Cyril in Joan. lib. iii. c. v. p. 302. [cf.
ταὐτοούσιον, p. 315, note 6.] It is uniformly asserted by the
Catholics that the Father’s godhead, θεότης, is the Son’s; e.g. infr. §52; supr. p.
329 b, line 8; p. 333, note 5; Orat. i. 49 fin. ii. §18.
§73. fin. iii. §26; iii. §5 fin. iii. §53;
μίαν
τὴν θεότητα
καὶ τὸ ἴδιον
τῆς οὐσίας
τοῦ πατρός. §56 supr. p. 84 fin. vid. §52. note. This
is an approach to the doctrine of the Una Res, defined in the fourth
Lateran Council [in 1215, see Harnack Dogmg. iii. 447, note, and
on the doctrine of the Greek Fathers, Prolegg. ch. ii. §3
(2) b.] of likeness Vid.
Epiph. Hær. 73. 9 fin.
between the Son and the Father, did not confess that the Son is like
the Father according to essence, or according to nature as a son
resembles his father, but because of Their agreement of doctrines and
of teaching §23, note 3.; nay, when they drew a line and an
utter distinction between the Son’s essence and the Father,
ascribing to Him an origin of being, other than the Father, and
degrading Him to the creatures, on this account the Bishops assembled
at Nicæa, with a view to the craft of the parties so thinking, and
as bringing together the sense from the Scriptures, cleared up the
point, by affirming the ‘Coessential;’ that both the true
genuineness of the Son might thereby be known, and that to things
originate might be ascribed nothing in common with Him. For the
precision of this phrase detects their pretence, whenever they use the
phrase ‘from God,’ and gets rid of all the subtleties with
which they seduce the simple. For whereas they contrive to put a
sophistical construction on all other words at their will, this phrase
only, as detecting their heresy, do they dread; which the Fathers set
down as a bulwark ἐπιτείχισμα; in like manner σύνδεσμον
πίστεως.
Epiph. Ancor. 6; cf. Hær. 69. 70; Ambros. de
Fid. iii. 15. against their
irreligious notions one and all.