See, we are proving that this view has been
transmitted from father to father; but ye, O modern Jews and disciples
of Caiaphas, how many fathers can ye assign to your phrases? Not one of
the understanding and wise; for all abhor you, but the devil alone Supr.
§5.; none but he is your father in this apostasy,
who both in the beginning sowed you with the seed of this irreligion, and now persuades you to slander
the Ecumenical Council vid.
supr. §4. Orat. i. §7. Ad Afros. 2, twice.
Apol. contr. Arian. 7. ad Ep. Æg. 5. Epiph.
Hær. 70. 9. Euseb. Vit. Const. iii. 6. The Council
was more commonly called μεγάλη,
vid. supr. §26. The second General Council, a.d. 381, took the name of ecumenical. vid. Can. 6. fin.
but incidentally. The Council of Ephesus so styles itself in the
opening of its Synodical Letter., for committing to
writing, not your doctrines, but that which from the beginning those
who were eye-witnesses and ministers of the Word have handed down to
us The
profession under which the decrees of Councils come to us is that of
setting forth in writing what has ever been held orally or implicitly
in the Church. Hence the frequent use of such phrases as ἐγγραφῶς
ἐξετέθη with reference to them. Thus Damasus, Theod. H. E. v. 10.
speaks of that ‘apostolical faith, which was set forth in
writing by the Fathers in Nicæa.’ On the other hand,
Ephrem of Antioch speaks of the doctrine of our Lord’s perfect
humanity being ‘inculcated by our Holy Fathers, but not as yet
[i.e. till the Council of Chalcedon] being confirmed by the
decree of an ecumenical Council.’ Phot. 229. p. 801.
(ἐγγραφῶς, however, sometimes relates to the act of subscribing; Phot.
ibid. or to Scripture, Clement. Strom. i. init. p. 321.)
Hence Athan. says ad Afros. 1. and 2. that ‘the Word of
the Lord which was given through the ecumenical Council in Nicæa
remaineth for ever;’ and uses against its opposers the
texts, ‘Remove not the ancient landmark which thy fathers have
set’ (vid. also Dionysius in Eus. H. E. vii. 7.), and
‘He that curseth his father or his mother, shall surely be put to
death.’ Prov. xxii. 28. Ex. xxi. 17. vid. also Athan. ad
Epict. 1. And the Council of Chalcedon professes to ‘drive
away the doctrines of error by a common decree, and renew the
unswerving faith of the Fathers,’ Act. v. p. 452. [t. iv. 1453
ed. Col.] ‘as,’ they proceed, ‘from of old the
prophets spoke of Christ, and He Himself instructed us, and the creed
of the Fathers has delivered to us,’ whereas ‘other faith
it is not lawful for any to bring forth, or to write, or to draw up, or
to hold, or to teach.’ p. 456. [1460 ed. Col.] vid. S. Leo. supr.
p. 5. note m. This, however, did not interfere with their adding
without undoing. ‘For,’ says Vigilius, ‘if it
were unlawful to receive aught further after the Nicene statutes, on
what authority venture we to assert that the Holy Ghost is of one
substance with the Father, which it is notorious was there
omitted?’ contr. Eutych. v. init.; he gives other
instances, some in point, others not. vid. also Eulogius, apud Phot.
Cod. 23. pp. 829. 853. Yet to add to the confession of the
Church is not to add to the faith, since nothing can be added to
the faith. Leo, Ep. 124. p. 1237. Nay, Athan. says that the
Nicene faith is sufficient to refute every heresy, ad Max. 5.
fin. (also Leo. Ep. 54. p. 956. and Naz. Ep. 102. init.)
excepting, however, the doctrine of the Holy Spirit; which
explains his meaning. The Henoticon of Zeno says the same, but with the
intention of dealing a blow at the Council of Chalcedon. Evagr. iii.
14. p. 345. Aetius at Chalcedon says that at Ephesus and Chalcedon the
Fathers did not profess to draw up an exposition of faith, and that
Cyril and Leo did but interpret the Creed. Conc. t. 2. p. 428.
[t. iv. 1430, 1431 ed. Col. See this whole subject very amply treated
in Dr. Pusey’s On the Clause, And the Son, pp. 76 sqq.]
Leo even says that the Apostles’ Creed is sufficient against all
heresies, and that Eutyches erred on a point ‘of which our Lord
wished no one of either sex in the Church to be ignorant,’ and he
wishes Eutyches to take the plentitude of the Creed ‘puro et
simplici corde.’ Ep. 31. p. 857, 8.. For the faith which the Council has
confessed in writing, that is the faith of the Catholic Church; to
assert this, the blessed Fathers so expressed themselves while
condemning the Arian heresy; and this is a chief reason why these apply
themselves to calumniate the Council. For it is not the terms which
trouble them Supr.
§21. init., but that those terms prove them to be
heretics, and presumptuous beyond other heresies.