a benefit, by procuring a resurrection: I would ask, what can be meant by turning or changing
it into a benefit, when it never was otherwise, nor could ever justly be otherwise? Infants
could not at all be brought under death as a calamity; for they never deserved it. And it would
be only an abuse (be it far from us, to ascribe such a thing to God) in any being, to offer any
poor sufferers a Redeemer from a calamity which he had brought upon them, without the
least desert of it on their part.
But it is plain, that mortality was not at first brought on mankind as a blessing, by the
covenant of grace through Christ; and that Christ and grace do not bring mankind under
death, but find them under it. 2 Cor. v. 14. “We thus judge, that if one died for all, then were
all dead.“ Luke xix. 10. “The Son of man is come to seek and save that which was lost.“ The
grace which appears in providing a deliverer from any state, supposes the subject to be in
that state prior to his deliverance. In our author’s scheme, there never could be any sentence
212
of death or condemnation, that requires a Savior from it; because the very sentence itself,
according to the true meaning of it, implies and makes sure all that good, which is requisite
to abolish and make void the seeming evil to the innocent subject. So that the sentence itself
is in effect the deliverer; and there is no need of another to deliver from that sentence. Dr.
T. insists upon it, that “nothing comes upon us in consequence of Adam’s sin, in any sense,
kind, or degree, inconsistent with the original blessing pronounced on Adam at his creation;
and nothing but what is perfectly consistent with God’s blessing, love, and goodness, declared
to Adam as soon as he came out of his Maker’s hands.” 107 If the case be so, it is certain
there is no evil or calamity at all for Christ to redeem us from; unless things agreeable to the
divine goodness, love, and blessing, are things from which we need redemption. 108
IV. It will follow, on our author’s principles, not only with respect to infants, but even
adult persons, that redemption is needless, and Christ is dead in vain. Not only is there no
need of Christ’s redemption in order to deliverance from any consequences of Adam’s sin,
but also in order to perfect freedom from personal sin, and all its evil consequences. For
God has made other sufficient provision for that, viz. a sufficient power and ability, in all
mankind, to do all their duty, and wholly to avoid sin. Yea, he insists upon it, that “when
men have not sufficient power to do their duty, they have no duty to do. We may safely and
assuredly conclude, (says he,) that mankind in all parts of the world have sufficient power
to do the duty which God requires of them; and that he requires of them no more than they
have sufficient powers to do.” 109 And in another place, 110 “God has given powers equal
107 Page 88. 89. S.
108 In this inferential short reply, our author it not quite so guarded as usual. It seems applicable only to infant;
since adults have actual or personal sin and guilt from which to be redeemed. But what immediately follows
anticipates the objection.—W.
109 Page 111. 68, 64. S.
110 Page 67. S.
1121
CHAPTER I. Proofs from Redemption by Christ.