As the speculation is two-fold,
concerning that life which is Divine, simple, and immaterial, and
concerning that existence which is material and subject to passion, and
as the word “generation” is used of both, we must needs
make our distinction sharp and clear, lest the ambiguity of the term
“generation” should in any way pervert the truth. Since,
then, the entrance into being through the flesh is material, and is
promoted by passion, while that which is bodiless, impalpable, without
form, and free from any material commixture, is alien from every
condition that admits of passion, it is proper to consider about what
sort of generation we are enquiring—that which is pure and
Divine, or that which is subject to passion and pollution. Now, no one,
I suppose, would deny that with regard to the Only-begotten God, it is
pre-temporal existence that is proposed for the consideration Reading, with the older editions, τῇ θεωρί&
139·. Oehler substitutes τὴν
θεωρίαν (a
variation which seems to give no good sense, unless θεωρία be translated as “subject of contemplation”),
but alleges no ms. authority for the
change. of Eunomius’ discourse. Why, then, does
he linger over this account of corporeal nature, defiling our nature by
the loathsome presentment of his argument, and setting forth openly the
passions that gather round human generation, while he deserts the
subject set before him? for it was not about this animal generation,
that is accomplished by means of the flesh, that we had any need to
learn. Who is so foolish, when he looks on himself, and considers human
nature in himself, as to seek another interpreter of his own nature,
and to need to be told all the unavoidable passions which are included
in the thought of bodily generation—that he who begets is
affected in one way, that which is begotten in another—so that
the man should learn from this instruction that he himself begets by
means of passion, and that passion was the beginning of his own
generation? For it is all the same whether these things are passed over
or spoken, and whether one publishes these secrets at length, or keeps
hidden in silence things that should be left unsaid, we are not
ignorant of the fact that our nature progresses by way of passion. But
what we are seeking is that a clear account should be given of the
exalted and unspeakable existence of the Only-begotten, whereby He is
believed to be of the Father.