(a) The supreme and unique revelation of
God to man is in the Person of the Incarnate Son. But though unique the
Incarnation is not solitary. Before it there was the divine institution
of the Law and the Prophets, the former a typical anticipation (de
Incarn. 40. 2) of the destined reality, and along with the latter
(ib. 12. 2 and 5) ‘for all the world a holy school of the
knowledge of God and the conduct of the soul.’ After it there is
the history of the life and teaching of Christ and the writings of His
first Disciples, left on record for the instruction of all ages.
Athanasius again and again applies to the Scriptures the terms θεία and θεόπνευστα
(e.g. de Decr. 15, de Incarn. 33. 3, &c.; the latter
word, which he also applies to his own martyr teachers, is, of course,
from 2 Tim. iii. 16). The implications of this as
bearing on the literal exactness of Scripture he nowhere draws out. His
strongest language (de Decr. ubi supra) is incidental to a
controversial point: on Ps. lii. (liii.) 2, he maintains that
‘there is no hyperbola in Scripture; all is strictly true,’
but he proceeds on the strength of that principle to allegorise the
verse he is discussing. In c. Gent. 2, 3, he treats the account
of Eden and the Fall as figurative. But in his later writings there is,
so far as I know, nothing to match this. In fact, although he always
employs the allegorical method, sometimes rather strangely (e.g. Deut. xxviii. 66, in de Incarn. 35, Orat.
ii. 19, after Irenæus, Origen, &c.), we discern, especially in
his later writings, a tendency toward a more literal exegesis than was
usual in the Alexandrian school. His discussion, e.g., of the
sinlessness of Christ (c. Apol. i. 7, 17, ii. 9, 10) contrasts
in this respect with that of his master Alexander, who appeals,
following Origen’s somewhat startling allegorical application, to
Prov. xxx. 19, a text nowhere used by Ath. in this way
(Thdt. H. E. i. 4). This is doubtless largely due to the
pressure of the controversy with the Arians, who certainly had more to
gain than their opponents from the prevalent unhistorical methods of
exegesis, as we see from the use made by them of 2 Cor. iv. 11 at Nicæa, and of Prov. viii. 22 throughout Athanasius is not always innocent of the method of which he
complains; e.g. when he uses Isa. i. 11, πλήρης
εἰμί, as a proof of the
Divine Perfection..
Accordingly Athanasius complains loudly of their exegesis (Ep.
Æg. 3–4, cf. Orat. i. 8, 52), and insists (id. i.
54, cf. already de Decr. 14) on the primary necessity of always
conscientiously studying the circumstances of time and place, the
person addressed, the subject matter, and purpose of the writer, in
order not to miss the true sense. This rule is the same as applies
(de Sent. Dion. 4) to the interpretation of any writings
whatever, and carries with it the strict subordination of the
allegorical to the historical sense, contended for by the later school
of Antioch, and now accepted by all reasonable Christians (see Kihn in
Wetzer-Hergenröther’s Kirchen-Lex. vol. i. pp.
955–959, who calls the Antiochene exegesis ‘certainly a
providential phenomenon;’ also supra, p. xxviii., note
1).