times declared, says that the Lord Jesus Christ was born of the Virgin Mary, only a mere
man: and so that Mary should be called Christotocos not Theotocos, because she was the
mother of Christ, not of God. And further to this blasphemous statement it adds arguments
that are as wicked as they are foolish, saying, “No one ever gave birth to one who was before
her.” As if the birth of the only begotten of God, predicted by prophets, announced since
the beginning of the world, could be dealt with or measured by human reasons. Or did the
Virgin Mary, O you heretic, whoever you are, who slander her for her childbearing—bring
about and consummate that which came to pass, by her own strength, so that in a matter
and event of so great importance, human weakness can be brought as an objection? And so
if there was anything in this great event which was the work of man, look for human argu-
ments. But if everything, which was done, was due to the power of God, why should you
consider what is impossible with men, when you see that it is the work of Divine power?
But of this more anon. Now let us follow up the subject we began to treat of some little way
back; that everybody may know that you are trying to fan the flame in the ashes of Pelagian-
ism, and to revive the embers by breathing out fresh blasphemy.
1461
Chapter I. He vehemently inveighs against the error of the Pelagians, who…