has faith, is sinful; because it is belying the Holy Ghost, denying his work in him, so there
is no sin to which that doubting can so properly be reduced as unbelief.”
Here I would ask leave thus to express my thoughts in a diversity from yours. I think,
if it be allowed to be sinful for a believer to doubt whether he has faith, that this doubting
is not the sin of unbelief on any such account as you mention, viz. as belying or denying
any testimony of the Holy Ghost. There is a difference between doubting of the being of
some work of the Holy Ghost, and denying the testimony of the Holy Ghost, as there is a
difference between doubting concerning some other works of God, and denying the testimony
of God. It is the work of God to give a man great natural abilities; and if we suppose God
requires such a man to believe the reality of his work in all its parts just as it is, and so that it
is sinful for him at all to doubt of his natural abilities being just as good as they are, yet this
is no belying any testimony of God, though, it be doubting of a work of God, and so is diverse
from the sin of unbelief. So, if we suppose a very eminent saint is to blame in doubting
whether he has so much grace as he really has; he indeed does not believe the reality of God’s
work in him, in all its parts, just as it is, yet he is not therein guilty of the sin of unbelief,
against any testimony of God, any more than the other. I acknowledge, that for a true saint
in a carnal and careless frame, to doubt of his good state, is sinful, more indirectly, as the
cause of it is sinful, viz. the lowness and insensibility of the actings of grace in him, and the
prevalence of carnality and stupidity. ‘Tis sinful to be without assurance, or, (as we say.) it
is his own fault, he sinfully deprives himself of it; or foregoes it, as a servant’s being without
his tools is his sin, when he has carelessly lost them, or as it is his sin to be without strength
of body, or without the sight of his eyes, when he has deprived himself of these by intemper-
ance. Not that weakness or blindness of body, in their own nature, are sin, for they are
qualities of the body, and not of mind, the subject in which sin is inherent. It is indirectly
the duty of a true saint always to rejoice in the light of God’s countenance, because sin is
the cause of his being without this joy at any time, and therefore it was indirectly David’s
sin that he was not rejoicing in the light of God’s countenance, at the very time when he
was committing the great iniquities of adultery and murder. But yet it is not directly a be-
liever’s duty to rejoice in the light of God’s countenance, when God hides his face. But it
rather then becomes him to be troubled and to mourn. So there are perhaps many other
privileges of saints that are their duty indirectly, and the want of them is sinful, not simply,
but complexly considered. Of this kind I take the want of assurance of my good estate to
be.
I think no words of mine, either in my book or letter, implied that a person’s deliverance
from a bad frame does not begin with renewed acts of faith or trusting in God. If they did,
they implied what I never intended. Doubtless if a saint comes out of an ill frame, wherein
grace is asleep and inactive, it must be by renewed actings of grace. It is very plainly im-
possible, that grace should begin to cease to be inactive, in any other way, than by its begin-
1496
II. To Mr. Gillespie, in answer to further objections.