Epiphanius relates the same thing of the
followers of Cerinthus, another section of the Gnostics, and says
it was continued in his time by a kind of tradition in Asia Minor
and in Galatia. Hær. xxviii. §. 6.
[The author justly derides this
custom and the endeavor to explain the passage as a reference to
it. Yet not a few of the soundest expositors hold that the
Apostle was referring to the practice of vicarious baptism, not
that he approved of it but as an argument ex concessu. See
the vindication of it in Hodge (in lo). To the same effect
DeWette, Meyer, Stanley, Alford, Heinrici, Beet, and the Principal
Edwards. On the other hand Canon Evans (in Bible
Commentary) contends strenuously for the interpretation of the
Greek Fathers, Theophylact, Theodoret, etc., and heartily approves
of Chrysostom’s scornful repudiation of the monstrous
superstition. He insists that vicarious baptism in its legitimate
issues must lead to something like salvation by proxy. Then he
asks, “Now if such a superstition, even in the germ, had appeared
in Corinth before the date of this epistle, would not Paul have
come down upon it with all his thunder? Would he not have devoted
a whole chapter to its extinction?” To me there seems but one
answer to these questions. If so, then the Apostle could not
referred to the practice, even in the way of an argumentum ad
hominem. C.]