(a) The case of Ischyras. This person had
been ordained presbyter by Colluthus, and his ordination had been, as
we have seen (§2), pronounced null and void by the Alexandrian
Council of 324. In spite of this he had persisted in carrying on his
ministrations at the village where he lived (Irene Secontaruri,
possibly the hamlet ‘Irene’ belonged to the township of S.,
there was a presbyter for the township, pp. 133, 145, but none at
Irene, p. 106). His place of worship was a cottage inhabited only by an
orphan child; of the few inhabitants of the place, only seven, and
those his own relations, would attend his services. During a visitation
of his diocese, Athanasius, had heard of this from the presbyter of the
township, and had sent Macarius, one of the clergy who were attending
him on his tour (cf. pp. 109, 139), to summon Ischyras for
explanations. Macarius found the poor man ill in bed and unable to
come, but urged his father to dissuade him from his irregular
proceedings. But instead of desisting, Ischyras joined the Meletians.
His first version of the matter appears to have been that Macarius had
used violence, and broken his chalice. The Meletians communicate this
to Eusebius, who eggs them on to get up the case. The story gradually
improves. Ischyras, it now appeared, had been actually celebrating the
Eucharist; Macarius had burst in upon him, and not only broken the
chalice but upset the Holy Table. In this form the tale had been
carried to Constantine when Athanasius was at Nicomedia. The relations
of Ischyras, however, prevailed upon him to recall his statements, and
he presented the Bishop with a written statement that the whole story
was false, and had been extorted from him by violence. Ischyras was
forgiven, but placed under censure, which probably led to his
eventually renewing the charge with increased bitterness. Athanasius
now was accused of personally breaking the chalice, &c. In
the letter of the council of Philippopolis the cottage of Ischyras
becomes a ‘basilica’ which Athanasius had caused to be
thrown down.