istered by these men while they were “dead” (for of them it was said in the notable decree
[of the Council of Bagai], that “the shores were full of dead men”), and by so doing swept
away the argument which you are accustomed to rest on a perverse interpretation of the
words: “Qui baptizatur a mortuo quid ei prodest lavacrum ejus?”2819 If, therefore, your
bishops had not said: “No case forecloses the investigation of another case, and no person
compromises the position of another person,” they would have been compelled to plead
guilty in the case of Primianus; but, in saying this, they declared the Catholic Church to be,
as we mentioned, not guilty in the case of Cæcilianus.
9. However, read all the rest and examine it well. Mark whether they have succeeded in
proving any charge of evil brought against Cæcilianus himself, through whose person they
attempted to compromise the position of the Church. Mark whether they have not rather
brought forward much that was in his favour, and confirmed the evidence that his case was
a good one, by a number of extracts which, to the prejudice of their own case, they produced
and read. Read these or let them be read to you. Consider the whole matter, ponder it care-
fully, and choose which you should follow: whether you should, in the peace of Christ, in
the unity of the Catholic Church, in the love of the brethren, be partaker of our joy, or, in
the cause of wicked discord, the Donatist faction and impious schism, continue to suffer
the annoyance caused to you by the measures which out of love to you we are compelled to
take.
10. I hear that you have remarked and often quote the fact recorded in the gospels, that
the seventy disciples went back from the Lord, and that they had been left to their own
choice in this wicked and impious desertion, and that to the twelve who alone remained the
Lord said, “Will ye also go away?”2820 But you have neglected to remark, that at that time
the Church was only beginning to burst into life from the recently planted seed, and that
there was not yet fulfilled in her the prophecy: “All kings shall fall down before Him; yea,
547
all nations shall serve Him;”2821 and it is in proportion to the more enlarged accomplishment
of this prophecy that the Church wields greater power, so that she may not only invite, but
even compel men to embrace what is good. This our Lord intended then to illustrate, for
although He had great power, He chose rather to manifest His humility. This also He taught,
2819 Ecclus. xxxiv. 25, translated, accurately enough, in our English version: “He that washeth himself after
touching a dead body, if he touch it again, what availeth his washing?” The Donatist, in quoting the passage to
support their practice of re-baptizing Catholics, omitted the clause, “et iterum tangit mortuum,” and translated
the sentence thus: “He that is baptized by one who is dead, what availeth his baptism?” It would be difficult to
quote from the annals of controversy a more flagrant example of ignorant ingenuity in the wresting of words
to serve a purpose.
2820 John vi. 67.
2821 Ps. lxxii. 11.
1158
To Donatus