5. In the above remarks I have assumed that I have made
alterations in the letter and that a simple translation may contain
errors though not wilful ones. As, however the letter itself shews that
no changes have been made in the sense, that nothing has been added,
and that no doctrine has been foisted into it, “obviously their
object is understanding to understand nothing;” Ter. And. prol.
17. and while they desire to arraign
another’s want of skill, they betray their own. For I myself not
only admit but freely proclaim that in translating from the Greek
(except in the case of the holy scriptures where even the order of the
words is a mystery) I render sense for sense and not word for word. For
this course I have the authority of
Tully who has so translated the Protagoras of Plato, the
Œconomicus of Xenophon, and the two beautiful orations The two speeches on
the Crown. which Æschines and Demosthenes
delivered one against the other. What omissions, additions, and
alterations he has made substituting the idioms of his own for those of
another tongue, this is not the time to say. I am satisfied to quote
the authority of the translator who has spoken as follows in a
prologue Only a small part
of this is extant. prefixed to the orations. “I
have thought it right to embrace a labour which though not necessary
for myself will prove useful to those who study. I have translated the
noblest speeches of the two most eloquent of the Attic orators, the
speeches which Æschines and Demosthenes delivered one against the
other; but I have rendered them not as a translator but as an orator,
keeping the sense but altering the form by adapting both the metaphors
and the words to suit our own idiom. I have not deemed it necessary to
render word for word but I have reproduced the general style and
emphasis. I have not supposed myself bound to pay the words out one by
one to the reader but only to give him an equivalent in value.”
Again at the close of his task he says, “I shall be well
satisfied if my rendering is found, as I trust it will be, true to this
standard. In making it I have utilized all the excellences of the
originals, I mean the sentiments, the forms of expression and the
arrangement of the topics, while I have followed the actual wording
only so far as I could do so without offending our notions of taste. If
all that I have written is not to be found in the Greek, I have at any
rate striven to make it correspond with it.” Horace too, an acute
and learned writer, in his Art of Poetry gives the same advice to the
skilled translator:—