Almost no fact of history is unquestioned; therefore the unquestionable authorship of
Eusebius has been questioned. Some have made the author Macarius (compare Vog. Hist.
lit. p. 12), evidently on the ground of the letter (3. 52) which the author says was addressed
to himself, but which is to Macarius and others, but there is no real doubt of the Eusebian
authorship. It was written after the death of Constantine (337), and therefore between 337
and 340, when Eusebius died. The interesting hypothesis of Meyer (p. 28) that it was perhaps
written mainly in Constantine’s lifetime, at the suggestion and under the direction of Con-
stantine, to defend him against charges brought, or which might be brought, against him,
is worth mentioning, although it is more ingenious than probable. The headings of the
chapters are by another, though probably not much later, and a competent hand (cf.
Lightfoot).
5. Trustworthiness of Eusebius
The value of a writer is determined by (1) His sources of knowledge, (2) His own intel-
468
lectual and moral ability. Again, the criticism of a given work seeks whether the aim pro
posed for that work has been truly fulfilled. A man who attempts a treatise on Geometry is
not to be criticised because he omits mention of sulphuric acid, or if he proposes a description
of Wagner’s music, because he does not produce a Helmholtz on Sound. The application
of these principles to Eusebius’ Life of Constantine requires brief examination of 1. The
proposed scope of the work. 2. The character of the sources. 3. The intellectual and moral
competency of Eusebius on the premises.
(1) The Scope of the Work. This is quite definitely outlined (i. 11). In contrast with those
who have recorded the evil deeds of other emperors and have thus “become to those who
by some favor had been kept apart from evil, teachers not of good, but of what should be
silenced in oblivion and darkness,” he proposes to record the noble actions of this emperor.
He proposes, however, to pass over many things,—his wars, personal bravery, victories, and
successes, his legislative acts, and many other things, and confine himself to such things as
have reference to his religious character. His aim, therefore, is distinctly limited to his reli-
gious acts, and it is not stretching his meaning too far to say, expressly limited to his virtuous
actions.
(2) Character of the Sources. Respecting this there is endless controversy. The fullness
of material is unquestionable, the intellectual competency of Eusebius is almost equally so,
and the questionings regard mainly whether the author has made a proper use of material.
Opinions are various, but this does not mean that they are equally well grounded and valu-
able. Some of the latest judgments are the most severe. Crivellucci (Livorno, 1888) calls it
an historical novel, and Görres, in a review of Crivellucci, agrees that it is worth less than
the Panegyrics of Eumenius and Nazarius, which is certainly milder than Manso’s (p. 222)
“more shameless and lying” than these. Right or wrong, this is a frequently repeated view.
Some (Hely, p. 141) cannot speak too strongly of the “contempt” which he “deserves,” and
1142
The Life of Constantine.