Repeat, then, Eunomius, repeat
this clever objection of yours to the Evangelist: “How dost thou
give the name of ‘Father’ in thy discourse, how that of
Only-begotten, seeing that all bodily generation is operated by
passion?” Surely truth answers you on his behalf, that the
mystery of theology is one thing, and the physiology of unstable bodies
is another. Wide is the interval by which they are fenced off one from
the other. Why do you join together in your argument what cannot blend?
how do you defile the purity of the Divine generation by your foul
discourse? how do you make systems for the incorporeal by the passions
that affect the body? Cease to draw your account of the nature of
things above from those that are below. I proclaim the Lord as the Son
of God, because the gospel from heaven, given through the bright cloud,
thus proclaimed Him; for “This,” He saith, “is My
beloved Son S. Matt. xvii. 5..” Yet, though I was taught that
He is the Son, I was not dragged down by the name to the earthly
significance of “Son,” but I both know that He is from the
Father and do not know that He is from passion. And this, moreover, I
will add to what has been said, that I know even a bodily generation
which is pure from passion, so that even on this point Eunomius’
physiology of bodily generation is proved false, if, that is to say, a
bodily birth can be found which does not admit passion. Tell me, was
the Word made flesh, or not? You would not, I presume, say that It was
not. It was so made, then, and there is none who denies it. How then
was it that “God was manifested in the flesh 1 Tim. iii.
16.
Here, as elsewhere in Gregory’s writings, it appears that he
read θεὸς
in this passage.”? “By birth,” of course you
will say. But what sort of birth do you speak of? Surely it is clear
that you speak of that from the virginity, and that “that which
was conceived in her was of the Holy Ghost S. Matt. i. 20,” and that “the days were
accomplished that she should be delivered, and she brought forth S. Luke ii. 6, 7.,” and none the less was her purity
preserved in her child-bearing. You believe, then, that that birth
which took place from a woman was pure from passion, if you do believe,
but you refuse to admit the Divine and incorruptible generation from
the Father, that you may avoid the idea of passion in generation. But I
know well that it is not passion he seeks to avoid in his doctrine, for
that he does not discern at all in the Divine and incorruptible nature;
but to the end that the Maker of all creation may be accounted a part
of creation, he builds up these arguments in order to a denial of the
Only-begotten God, and uses his pretended caution about passion to help
him in his task.