and that they received and loved him as such, when at the same time they hated him, and
did not believe he was the Messiah.—But here is no requiring and forbidding the same thing
at the same time: for the only thing required of them was, to have faith and love, and to
testify it; which was not at all forbidden.
(2.) None of the difficulties, which Mr. S. or Mr. W. object—either God’s supposed re-
quiring impossibilities, or his requiring and forbidding at the same time—do follow, any
more on my principles, than on Mr. W.‘s. Mr. W. maintains, that God calls men this moment
to enter into covenant with him, and commands them to do it. (p. 28. c.) One thing implied
in this, according to his own frequent explanation of visibly entering into covenant, is pro-
fessing a belief of the fundamental doctrines of Christianity. Now therefore, we will suppose
a man to be a candidate for baptism, who has been brought up in Arianism; and is strongly
persuaded, that the doctrine of the trinity is not true: yet he is this moment required to
profess that doctrine; but has no ability in a moment to believe the doctrine, because he
does not at present see the evidence of it. For as Mr. W. himself says, (Sermon on Christ a
King and Witness, p. 91. d. e. and 92. a.) “The understanding cannot be brought to yield its
assent to any truth, which it does not see the truth or apprehend the evidence of.—If you
would hire him with cart-loads or ship-loads of gold and silver; if you should imprison him,
whip him, burn him; you cannot make him believe a thing to be true, which he apprehends
to be incredible, or which he sees no sufficient reason to believe.” Now therefore what shall
the man do, on Mr. W.’s principles? He is commanded to profess the doctrine of the Trinity,
which must be professed in order to be lawfully baptized in the name of the Trinity; and on
Mr. W.‘s principles, he is commanded to do it this moment. Yet also on his principles, if the
man professes it, and is not morally sincere, or knows he does not believe it, he is guilty of
horrible falsehood and prevarication; which God doubtless forbids. Therefore here is certainly
as much of an appearance of commanding and forbidding the same thing at the same time,
as in the other case.
Every husbandman in Israel, that lived even in Christ’s time, was required to offer a
basket of the first-fruits; and was commanded when he offered it, solemnly to make that
profession, concerning the principal facts relating to the redemption out of Egypt,—which
is prescribed in . “A Syrian ready to perish was my father,” &c. Now supposing there had
been an Israelite, who did not believe the truth of all these facts, which came to pass so many
ages before, (as there are now many in christendom, who do not believe the facts concerning
Jesus Christ,) and continued in his unbelief, till the very moment of his offering: God per-
emptorily requires him to make this profession; yet none will say, that he may lawfully
profess these things, at the same time when he does not believe them to be true. However,
here is no commanding and forbidding the same thing at the same time: because, though
God required the Jews to make this profession, yet the thing required was to believe it and
profess it. Though some might not believe it, nor be able for the present to believe it; yet this
2026
SECTION XVII. Of commanding to partake.