The above-mentioned Emeritus was present at a Synod of the Catholics, near Deuterius,
September 20, 418. At a service held two days after, Augustin preached the Sermo ad
Cæsariensis Ecclesiæ plebem. Emeritus was present. In the church during a previous colloquy
with Augustin he had said: I cannot will what you will, but I can will what I will. Augustin
in this sermon (and the writing has all the abruptness and repetition of an extempore address)
400
urges him to will what God wills, viz., peace, and that now, in response to the cry of the
people; and if you ask why I, who call you schismatics and heretics, desire to receive you, it
is because you are brethren; because you have the baptism of Christ; because I want you to
have salvation: one can have everything outside the Church except salvation; he can have
honor, he can have the sacraments, he can sing Allelulia, he can respond Amen, he can hold
to the gospels, he can have faith in the name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit,
and can preach. Persecution after all is rather of you. The failure of the archival evidence
as to Cæcilian is alleged as usual, and hence no reason for separation exists. He recites too
the story of the seizure, escape, reseizure, compulsory baptism and ordination of Petilian,
while at the time a Catholic catechumen. This occurred at Constantina, when that city and
region were largely Donatist. He was seized unto death, do we not draw him to salvation?
Here or nowhere, says Augustin, repeating the voice of the people, is the place for peace.
There was a gathering of clergy (the bishops Alypius, Augustinus, Possidius, Rusticus
Palladius, etc., many presbyters and deacons and a considerable number of people) in the
exedra of the larger church at Cæsarea, c. 418 A.D. Emeritus, the Donatist bishop of the
city, was also present. Augustin addresses those devoted to the unity, and says that when
he came to the city on the day before yesterday he found Emeritus returned from a journey.
Augustin met him in the street and invited him to the Church, and Emeritus consented
without any demur. The sermon of Augustin is full of the peace, love and related themes
of the Church, in hope of winning Emeritus. He alludes to the many conversions in the city
and since the collation; if Emeritus has anything new to say in defense of his side, he invites
him to state it. Emeritus had been reported as affirming that at the Conference the Donatists
were overcome by power rather than by truth. Augustin then addresses inquiries to Emer-
itus directly: as to why he had come if he was defeated at the council; or if he thought his
party had triumphed, then to state the ground for such an opinion. Emeritus said: The acts
show whether I am defeated or not, whether I am defeated by truth or oppressed by power.
Augustin: Then why do you come? Emeritus: That I might say this very thing which you
ask, and so on. Under some taunting and arrogant observations to the brethren, Emeritus
keeps quiet. From Augustin’s statement it appears that the Acts were read during Lent, at
Thagaste, Constantina, Hippo, and all the faithful churches. Part of these Gesta are then
read by Alypius, viz, the imperial convocation of the Conference, and comments are made
by Augustin. Then follows his application of the lessons afforded by the Maximianist schism,
in which he says the Donatists make shipwreck of all their tenets. Emeritus, however, re-
683
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.