§13. Résumé of his dogmatic teaching. Objections to it in detail.
But somehow our discourse has swerved considerably from the mark; it has had to turn
round and face each of this slanderer’s insults. To Eunomius indeed it is no small advantage
that the discussion should linger upon such points, and that the indictment of his offences
against man should delay our approach to his graver sins. But it is profitless to abuse for
hastiness of speech one who is on his trial for murder; (because the proof of the latter is
sufficient to get the verdict of death passed, even though hastiness of speech is not proved
along with it); just so it seems best to subject to proof his blasphemy only, and to leave his
insults alone. When his heinousness on the most important points has been detected, his
50
other delinquencies are proved potentially without going minutely into them. Well then; at
the head of all his argumentations stands this blasphemy against the definitions of the
Faith—both in his former work and in that which we are now criticizing—and his strenuous
effort to destroy and cancel and completely upset all devout conceptions as to the Only-
Begotten Son of God and the Holy Spirit. To show, then, how false and inconsistent are his
arguments against these doctrines of the truth, I will first quote word for word his whole
statement, and then I will begin again and examine each portion separately. “The whole
account of our doctrines is summed up thus; there is the Supreme and Absolute Being, and
another Being existing by reason of the First, but after It104 though before all others; and a
third Being not ranking with either of these, but inferior to the one, as to its cause, to the
other, as to the energy which produced it: there must of course be included in this account
104 there is the Supreme and Absolute Being, and another Being existing through the First, but after It. The
language of this exposition of Eunomius is Aristotelian: but the contents nevertheless are nothing more nor less
than Gnosticism, as Rupp well points out (Gregors v. Nyssa Leben und Meinungen, p. 132 sq.). Arianism, he
says, is nothing but the last attempt of Gnosticism to force the doctrine of emanations into Christian theology,
clothing that doctrine on this occasion in a Greek dress. It was still an oriental heresy, not a Greek heresy like
Pelagianism in the next century. Rupp gives two reasons why Arianism may be identified with Gnosticism. 1.
Arianism holds the Λόγος as the highest being after the Godhead, i.e. as the πρωτότοκος τῆς κτίσεως, and as
merely the mediator between God and Man: just as it was the peculiar aim of Gnosticism to bridge over the gulf
between the Creator and the Created by means of intermediate beings (the emanations). 2. Eunomius and his
master adopted that very system of Greek philosophy which had always been the natural ally of Gnosticism: i.e.
Aristotle is strong in divisions and differences, weak in ‘identifications:’ he had marked with a clearness never
attained before the various stages upwards of existencies in the physical world: and this is just what Gnosticism,
in its wish to exhibit all things according to their relative distances from the ᾽Αγέννητος, wanted. Eunomius has
in fact in this formula of his translated all the terms of Scripture straight into those of Aristotle: he has changed
the ethical-physical of Christianity into the purely physical; πνεύμα e.g. becomes οὐσία: and by thus banishing
the spiritual and the moral he has made his ᾽Αγέννητος as completely ‘single’ and incommunicable as the τὸ
πρῶτον κίνουν ἀκίνητον (Arist. Metaph. XII. 7).
Résumé of his dogmatic teaching. Objections to it in detail.
93
Résumé of his dogmatic teaching. Objections to it in detail.