Chapter 21.—23. Lastly, it has been said, as he himself has also quoted, "Ye shall know
them by their fruits:"1956 let us therefore examine into their fruits. You bring up against
our predecessors their delivery of the sacred books. This very charge we urge with greater
probability against their accusers themselves. And not to carry our search too far, in the
same city of Constantina your predecessors ordained Silvanus bishop at the very outset of
his schism. He, while he was still a subdeacon, was most unmistakeably entered as a traditor
in the archives of the city. 1957 If you on your side bring forward documents against our
predecessors, all that we ask is equal terms, that we should either believe both to be true or
both to be false. If both are true, you are unquestionably guilty of schism, who have pretended
that you avoid offenses in the communion of the whole world, which you had commonly
among you in the small fragment of your own sect. But again, if both are false, you are un-
questionably guilty of schism, who, on account of the false charges of giving up the sacred
books, are staining yourselves with the heinous offence of severance from the Church. But
if we have something to urge in accusation while you have nothing, or if our charges are
true whilst yours are false, it is no longer matter of discussion how thoroughly your mouths
are closed.
1956 Matt. vii. 16.
1957 See below, III. 57, 69; 68, 70; and Contra Cresc. III. 29, 33, IV. 56, 66.
Chapter 21
1002
Chapter 21