Susannah, and another thing to receive the sacrament of the Lord in company with a thief,
as the apostles received even that first supper in company with Judas. I am all in favor of
544
your defense. But why do you not consider how much more easily, in the course of your
defense, you have acquitted all the nations and boundaries of the earth, throughout which
the inheritance of Christ is dispersed? For if it was possible for you to see a thief, and to
share the sacraments with the thief whom you saw, and yet not to share his sin, how much
less was it possible for the remotest nations of the earth to have anything in common with
the sins of African traditors and persecutors, supposing your charges and assertions to be
true, even though they held the sacraments in common with them? Or do you say, I saw
in him the bishop, I did not see in him the thief? Say what you will. I allow this defense
also, and in this the world is acquitted of the charges which you brought against it. For if
it was permitted you to ignore the character of a man whom you knew, why is the whole
world not allowed to be ignorant of those it never knew, unless, indeed, the Donatists are
allowed to be ignorant of what they do not wish to know, while the nations of the earth may
not be ignorant of what they cannot know?
54. Or do you say, Theft is one thing, delivery of the sacred books or persecution is
another? I grant there is a difference, nor is it worth while now to show wherein that differ-
ence consists. But listen to the summary of the argument. If he could not make you a thief,
because his thieving was displeasing in your sight, who can make men traditors or murderers
to whom such treachery or murder is abhorrent? First, then, confess that you share in all
the evil of Optatus, whom you knew, and even so reproach me with any evil which was
found in those whom I knew not. And do not say to me, But my charges are serious, yours
but trifling. You must first acknowledge them, however trifling they may be in your case,
not before I on my side confess the charges against me, but before I can allow you to say
these serious things about me at all. Did Optatus, whom you knew make you a thief by being
your colleague, or not? Answer me one or the other. If you say he did not, I ask why he did
not,—because he was not a thief himself? or because you do not know it? or because you
disapprove of it? If you say, Because he himself was not a thief, much more ought we not
to believe that those with whom you reproach us were of such a character as you assert. For
if we must not believe of Optatus what both Christians and pagans and Jews, ay, and what
both our party and yours assert, how much less should we believe what you assert of any
one? But if you say, Because you do not know it, all the nations of the earth answer you,
Much more do we not know of all that you reproach us with in these men. But if you say,
Because you disapproved of it, they answer you with the same voice, Although you have
never proved the truth of what you say, yet acts like these are viewed by us with disapproval.
But if you say, Lo, Optatus, whom I knew, made me a thief because he was my colleague,
and I was in the habit of going to the altar with him when he committed those deeds; but I
do not greatly heed it, because the fault was trivial, but your party made you a traditor and
1046
Chapter 23