Thus the thought of salvation by works greatly
preponderates over that of salvation by grace. Hilary is fearful
of weakening man’s sense of moral responsibility by dwelling too
much upon God’s work which, however, he does not fail to
recognise. Of the two great dangers, that of faith and that of
life, the former seemed to him the more serious. God’s
requirements in that respect were easy of fulfilment; He had stated the
truth and He expected it to be unhesitatingly accepted. But if
belief, being an exertion of the will, was easy, misbelief must be
peculiarly and fatally wicked. The confession of St. Peter, the
foundation upon which the Church is built, is that Christ is
God Trin. vi.
36.; the sin against the Holy Ghost is denial
of this truth Comm. in
Matt. xii. 17, xxxi. 5.. These are
the highest glory and the deepest shame of man. It does not seem
that Hilary regarded any man, however depraved, as beyond hope so long
as he did not dispute this truth; he has no code of mortal sins.
But heresy concerning Christ, whatever the conduct and character of the
heretic, excludes all possibility of salvation, for it necessarily cuts
him off from the one Faith and the one Church which are the condition
and the sphere of growth towards perfection; and the
severance is just, because
misbelief is a wilful sin. Since, then, compliance or
non-compliance with one of God’s demands, that for faith in His
revelation, depends upon the will, it was natural that Hilary should
lay stress upon the importance of the will in regard to God’s
other demand, that for a Christian life. This was, in a sense, a
lighter requirement, for various degrees of obedience were
possible. Conduct could neither give nor deny faith, but only
affect its growth, while without the frank recognition of the facts of
religion no conduct could be acceptable to God. Life presents to
the will a constantly changing series of choices between good and evil,
while the Faith must be accepted or rejected at once and as a
whole. It is clear from Hilary’s insistence upon this that
the difficulties, apart from heresy, with which he had to contend
resembled those of Mission work in modern India. There were many
who would accept Christianity as a revelation, yet had not the moral
strength to live in conformity with their belief. Of such persons
Hilary will not despair. They have the first essential of
salvation, a clear and definite acceptance of doctrinal truth; they
have also the offer of sufficient grace, and the free will and power to
use it. And time and opportunity are granted, for the
vicissitudes of life form a progressive education; they are, if taken
aright, the school, the training-ground for immortality Trin. i.
14.. This is because all Christians are
in Christ, by virtue of His Incarnation. They are, as St. Paul
says, complete in Him, furnished with the faith and hope they
need. But this is only a preparatory completeness; hereafter they
shall be complete in themselves, when the perfect harmony is attained
and they are conformed to his glory Ib. ix. 8,
commenting on Col. ii.
10.. Thus
to the end the dignity and responsibility of mankind is
maintained. But it is obvious that Hilary has failed to correlate
the work of Christ with the work of the Christian. The necessity
of His guidance and aid, and the manner in which these are bestowed, is
sufficiently stated, and the duty of the Christian man is copiously and
eloquently enforced. But the importance of Christ’s work
within Himself, in harmonising the two natures, has withdrawn most of
Hilary’s attention from His work within the believing soul; and
the impression which Hilary’s writings leave upon the mind
concerning the Saviour and redeemed mankind is that of allied forces
seeking the same end but acting independently, each in a sphere of its
own.