It is unnecessary to detail the tedious and
unedifying story of the councils of Arles and Milan. The former was a
provincial council of Gaul, attended by legates of the Roman see. All
present submissively registered the imperial condemnation of
Athanasius. The latter, delayed till 355 by the Rhenish campaign of
Constantius, was due to the request of Liberius, who desired to undo
the evil work of his legates, and to the desire of the Emperor to
follow up the verdict of a provincial with that of a more
representative Synod. The number of bishops present was probably very
small (the numbers in Socrates ii. 36, Soz. iv. 9, may refer to those
who afterwards signed under compulsion, p. 280, cf. the case of
Sardica, p. 127, note 10). The proceedings were a drama in three acts,
first, submission, the legates protesting; secondly, stormy protest,
after the arrival of Eusebius of Vercellæ; thirdly, open coercion.
The deposition of Athanasius was proffered to each bishop for
signature, and, if he refused, a sentence of banishment was at once
pronounced, the emperor sitting with the ‘velum’ drawn,
much as though an English judge were to assume the black cap at the
beginning of a capital trial. He cut short argument by
announcing that ‘he was for the prosecution,’ and
remonstrance by the sentence of exile (p. 299); the ὅπερ
ἐγὼ βούλομαι
τούτο κανών
put into his mouth by Athanasius (p. 281) represents at any rate the
spirit of his proceedings as justly
as does ‘la tradizione son’ io’ that of the
autocrat of a more recent council. At this council no creed was put
forth: until the enemy was dislodged from Alexandria the next step
would be premature. But a band of exiles were sent in strict custody to
the East, of some of whom we shall hear later on (pp. 561, 481, 281,
cf. p. 256, and the excellent monograph of Krüger, Lucifer von
Calaris, pp. 9–23).