CHAP. IV.] ALL MEN DESIRE BLESSEDNESS. 315
has said : that " all mortals wish themselves to be praised
;
"
wherein, doubtless, he conjectured what was in others, both
by himself, and by those whom he knew by experience ; and
so seems to have declared what it is that allmen will. Lastly,
if that comic actor himself, too, had said. You all will to be
praised, no one of you wills to be abused; he would have
seemed in like manner to have expressed what all will. Yet
there are some who hate their own faults, and do not desire
to be praised by others for that for which they are displeased
with themselves ; and who thank the kindness of those who
rebuke them, when the purpose of that rebuke is their own
amendment. But if he had said. You all will to be blessed,
you do not will to be wretched ; he would have said some-
thing which there is no one that would not recognise in his
own will. Tor whatever else a man may will secretly, he
does not withdraw from that will, which is well known to all
men, and well known to be in all men.
Chap. iv.—The will to possess blessedness is one in all, hut the variety of wills
is very great concerning that blessedness itself.
7. It is wonderful, however, since the will to obtain and
retain blessedness is one in all, whence comes, on the other
hand, such a variety and diversity of wills concerning that
blessedness itself; not that any one is unwilling to have it,
but that all do not know it. For if all knew it, it would not
be thought by some to be in goodness of mind ; by others, in
pleasure of body ; by others, in both ; and by some in one
thing, by others in another. For as men find special delight
in this thing or that, so have they placed in it their idea
of a blessed life. How, then, do all love so warmly what
not all know ? Who can love what he does not know ?—
a
subject which I have already discussed in the preceding
books.^ Why, therefore, is blessedness loved by all, when
it is not known by all 1 Is it perhaps that all know what it
is itself, but all do not know where it is to be found, and that
the dispute arises from this ?—as if, forsooth, the business was
about some place in this world, where every one ought to will to
live who wills to live blessedly ; and as if the question where
blessedness is were not implied in the question what it is.
1 Bks. viii. c. 4, etc., x. c. 1.