when you say, “I do not know what his character was.” How much more obvious, then, is
it that the Eastern world knows nothing of the character of those Africans with whom,
though much less known to you than Optatus, you find fault! Yet you are disjoined by
scandalous schism from Churches in the East, the names of which you have and you read
in the sacred books. If your most famous and most scandalously notorious Bishop of
Thamugada2091 was at that very time not known to his colleague, I shall not say in Cæsarea,
but in Sitifa, so close at hand, how was it possible for the Churches of Corinth, Ephesus,
Colosse, Philippi, Thessalonica, Antioch, Pontus, Galatia, Cappadocia, and others which
were founded in Christ by the apostles, to know the case of these African traditors, whoever
they were; or how was it consistent with justice that they should be condemned by you for
not knowing it? Yet with these Churches you hold no communion. You say they are not
Christian, and you labour to rebaptize their members. What need I say? What complaint,
what protest is necessary here? If I am addressing a right-hearted man, I know that with
you I share the keenness of the indignation which I feel. For you doubtless see at once what
I might say if I would.
6. Perhaps, however, your forefathers formed of themselves a council, and placed the
whole Christian world except themselves under sentence of excommunication. Have you
come so to judge of things, as to affirm that the council of the followers of Maximianus who
were cut off from you, as you were cut off from the Church, was of no authority against you,
because their number was small compared with yours; and yet claim for your council an
authority against the nations, which are the inheritance of Christ, and the ends of the earth,
which are His possession?2092 I wonder if the man who does not blush at such pretensions
has any blood in his body. Write me, I beseech you, in reply to this letter; for I have heard
from some, on whom I could not but rely, that you would write me an answer if I were to
address a letter to you. Some time ago, moreover, I sent you a letter; but I do not know
whether you received it or answered it, and perhaps your reply did not reach me. Now,
however, I beg you not to refuse to answer this letter, and state what you think. But do not
occupy yourself with other questions than the one which I have stated, for this is the leading
point of a well-ordered discussion of the origin of the schism.
7. The civil powers defend their conduct in persecuting schismatics by the rule which
the apostle laid down: “Whoso resisteth the power, resisteth the ordinance of God; and they
that resist shall receive to themselves judgment. For rulers are not a terror to good works,
but to the evil. Wilt thou then not be afraid of the power? Do that which is good, and thou
shalt have praise of the same: for he is the minister of God to thee for good. But if thou do
that which is evil, be afraid; for he beareth not the sword in vain: for he is the minister of
2091 Optatus.
2092 Ps. ii. 8.
818
To Emeritus