CHAP. Vni.] CHRISTIAN RELIGION. 86
witnesses of the events ? Is it probable that he would make
his appearance in public, and, accusing the people of infidelity,
contumacy, mgratitude, and other crimes, boast that his doc-
trine had been confirmed in their sight by miracles which they
had never seen ?
VI. For this also is worthy of being remarked, that all his
accounts of miracles are connected with such unpleasant cir-
cumstances, as were calculated to stimulate all the people, if
there had been but the smallest occasion, to a public and pos-
itive contradiction ; whence it appears, that they were induced
to coincide with him only by the ample conviction of theit
own experience. But since the matter was too evident foi
profane writers to take the liberty of denying the performance
of miracles by Moses, the father of lies has suggested the
calumny of ascribing them to magical arts. But by what
kind of conjecture can they pretend to charge him with having
been a magician, who had so great an abhorrence of that su-
perstition, as to command, that he who merely consulted
magicians and soothsayers should be stoned ? (6) Certainly
no impostor practises such juggling tricks, who does not make
it his study, for the sake of acquiring fame, to astonish the
minds of the vulgai-. But what is the practice of Moses ?
Openly avowing that himself and his brother Aaron are noth-
ing, (c) but that they only execute the commands of God, he
sufficiently cleai-s his character from every unfavourable as-
persion. Now, if the events themselves be considered, whai
incantation could cause manna to rain daily from heaven suf
ficient to support the people, and, if any one laid up more
than the proper quantity, cause it to putrefy, as a punishment
from God for his unbelief? Add also the many serious ex-
aminations which God permitted his servant to undergo, so
that the clamour of the wicked can now be of no avail. For
as often as this holy servant of God was in danger of being
destroyed, at one time by proud and petulant insurrections of
all the people, at another by the secret conspiracies of a few,
—how was it possible for him to elude their inveterate rage by
any arts of deception ? And the event evidently proves, that
by these circumstances his doctrine was confirmed to all suc-
ceeding ages.
VII. Moreover, who can deny that his assigning, in the
person of the patriarch Jacob, the supreme power to the tribe
of Judah, proceeded from a spirit of prophecy, (d) especially
if we consider the eventual accomplishment of this prediction ?
Suppose Moses to have been the first author of it
;
yet after
he committed it to writing, there elapsed four hundred '/ears
(b) Lev. XX. 6. (c) Exod. xvi. 7. (d) Gen. xJit. 10.