798 The author of the so-called Epistle of Barnabas is unknown. No name appears in the epistle itself, and no
hints are given which enable us to ascribe it to any known writer. External testimony, without a dissenting voice,
ascribes it to Barnabas, the companion of Paul. But this testimony, although unanimous, is neither very strong
nor very extensive. The first to use the epistle is Clement of Alexandria, who expressly and frequently ascribes
it to Barnabas the companion of Paul. Origen quotes from the epistle twice, calling it the Epistle of Barnabas,
but without expressing any judgment as to its authenticity, and without defining its author more closely. Jerome
(de vir. ill. 6) evidently did not doubt its authenticity, but placed it nevertheless among the Apocrypha, and his
opinion prevailed down to the seventeenth century. It is difficult to decide what Eusebius thought in regard to
its authorship. His putting it among the νόθοι here does not prove that he considered it unauthentic (see note
1, above); nor, on the other hand, does his classing it among the Antilegomenajust below prove that he considered
it authentic, but non-apostolic, as some have claimed. Although, therefore, the direct external testimony which
we have is in favor of the apostolic Barnabas as its author, it is to be noticed that there must have existed a
widespread doubt as to its authenticity, during the first three centuries, to have caused its complete rejection
from the canon before the time of Eusebius. That this rejection arose from the fact that Barnabas was not himself
one of the twelve apostles cannot be. For apostolic authorship was not the sole test of canonicity, and Barnabas
stood in close enough relation to the apostles to have secured his work a place in the canon, during the period
of its gradual formation, had its authenticity been undoubted. We may therefore set this inference over against
the direct external testimony for Barnabas’ authorship. When we come to internal testimony, the arguments
are conclusive against “the Levite Barnabas” as the author of the epistle. These arguments have been well stated
by Donaldson, in his History of Christian Literature, I. p. 204 sqq. Milligan, in Smith and Wace’s Dict. of Christ.
Biog., endeavors to break the force of these arguments, and concludes that the authenticity of the epistle is highly
probable; but his positions are far from conclusive, and he may be said to stand almost alone among modern
scholars. Especially during the last few years, the verdict against the epistle’s authenticity has become practically
unanimous. Some have supposed the author to have been an unknown man by the name of Barnabas: but this
is pure conjecture. That the author lived in Alexandria is apparently the ruling opinion, and is quite probable.
It is certain that the epistle was written between the destruction of Jerusalem (a.d. 70) and the time of Clement
of Alexandria: almost certain that it was written before the building of Ælia Capitolina; and probable that it was
written between 100 and 120, though dates ranging all the way from the beginning of Vespasian’s reign to the
end of Hadrian’s have been, and are still, defended by able scholars. The epistle is still extant in a corrupt Greek
original and in an ancient Latin translation. It is contained in all the editions of the Apostolic Fathers (see especially
Gebhardt and Harnack’s second edition, 1876, and Hilgenfeld’s edition of 1877). An English translation is given
in the Ante-Nicene Fathers, Vol. I. p. 133 sqq. For the most important literature, see Schaff, Ch. Hist. II. p. 671
sqq., and Gebhardt and Harnack’s edition, p. xl. sqq.
799 τῶν ἀποστόλων αἰ λεγόμεναι διδαχαί. The Teaching of the Twelve Apostles, Διδαχὴ τῶν δώδεκα
ἀποστόλων, a brief document in sixteen chapters, was published in 1884 by Philotheos Bryennios, Metropolitan
of Nicomedia, from a ms. discovered by him in the Jerusalem convent in Constantinople in 1873. The discovery
threw the whole theological world into a state of excitement, and the books and articles upon the subject from
America and from every nation in Europe have appeared by the hundred. No such important find has been
made for many years. The light which the little document has thrown upon early Church history is very great,
326
The Divine Scriptures that are accepted and those that are not.