266 INSTITUTES OF THE [bOOK II.
that man sins less voluntarily, because he is under a necessity
of sinning ? This necessity Augustine every where maintains
;
and even when he was pressed with the cavils of Celestius,
who tried to throw an odium on this doctrine, he confidently
expressed himself in these terms : "By means of liberty it \
came to pass that man fell into sin ; but now the penal depra- |
vity consequent on it, instead of liberty, has introduced necessi- /
ty." And whenever the mention of this subject occurs, he
hesitates not to speak in this manner of the necessary servitude
of sin. We must therefore observe this grand point of distinc-
tion, thatjnan, having been corrupted by his fall, sins yohuita-
rily, not with reluctance or constraint ; with the strongest
propensity of disposition, not with violent coercion ; with the
bias of his own passions, and not with external compulsion :
yet such is the pravity of his nature, that he cannot be excited
and bicissed to any thing but what is evil. If this be true,
there is no impropriety in affirming, that he is under a necessi-
ty of sinning. Bernard, subscribing to what is said by Augus-
tine, thus expresses himself: " Among all the animals, man
alone is free ; and yet, by the intervention of sin, he also suffers
a species of violence ; but from the will, not from natme, so
that he is not thereby deprived of his innate liberty." For
what is voluntary is also free. And a little after : " The will
being, by I know not what corrupt and surprising means,
changed for the worse, is itself the author of the necessity to
which it is subject ; so that neither necessity, being voluntary,
can excuse the will, nor the will, being fascinated, can exclude
necessity." For this necessity is in some measure voluntary.
Afterwards he says, that we are oppressed with a yoke, but no
other than that of a voluntary servitude ; that therefore our
servitude renders us miserable, and our will renders us inexcu-
sable ; because the will, when it was free, made itself the slave
of sin. At length he concludes, " Thus the soul, in a certain
strange and evil manner, under this kind of voluntary and free
yet pernicious necessity, is both enslaved and free ; enslaved
by necessity, free by its will ; and, what is more wonderful
and more miserable, it is guilty, because free ; and enslaved
wherein it is guilty ; and so therein enslaved wherein it is
free." From these passages the reader clearly perceives that 1
am teaching nonovel doctrjne, but wjiat was long"ago advanced
by AugusTme ^ with^eiiniversal consenf of pious men, and
iwhich tof~nearlyITlEousand years after was confined to the
^ cloisters of monks. ButLuinijard, for want of knowing how
to distingiiiab^ecessityjromlcoaction, gave rise .tOLa_2gmicious
error.
VI. It is necessary, on the other hand, to consider the remedy
jf Divine grace, by which the depravity of nature is corrected