29. Manes said: Is not that word also to the same effect which Jesus spake to the disciples,
when He was demonstrating those men to be unbelieving: “Ye are of your father the devil,
202
and the lusts of your father ye will do?”1706 By this He means, in sooth, that whatever the
wicked prince of this world desired, and whatever he lusted after, he committed to writing
through Moses, and by that medium gave it to men for their doing. For “he was a murderer
from the beginning, and abode not in the truth, because there is no truth in him. When he
speaketh a lie, he speaketh of his own: for he is a liar, and the father of it.”1707 Archelaus
said: Are you satisfied1708 with what you have already adduced, or have you other statements
still to make? Manes said: I have, indeed, many things to say, and things of greater weight
even than these. But with these I shall content myself. Archelaus said: By all means. Now let
us select some instance from among those statements which you allege to be on your side;
so that if these be once found to have been properly dealt with, other questions may also be
held to rank with them; and if the case goes otherwise, I shall come under the condemnation
of the judges, that is to say, I shall have to bear the shame of defeat.1709 You say, then, that
the law is a ministration of death, and you admit that “death, the prince of this world, reigned
from Adam even to Moses;”1710 for the word of Scripture is this: “even over them that did
not sin.”1711 Manes said: Without doubt death did reign thus, for there is a duality, and
these two antagonistic powers were nothing else than both unbegotten.1712 Archelaus said:
Tell me this then,—how can an unbegotten death take a beginning at a certain time? For
“from Adam” is the word of Scripture, and not “before Adam.” Manes said: But tell me, I
ask you in turn, how it obtained its kingdom over both the righteous and the sinful. Archelaus
said: When you have first admitted that it has had that kingdom from a determinate time
and not from eternity, I shall tell you that. Manes said: It is written, that “death reigned from
Adam to Moses.” Archelaus said: And consequently it has an end, because it has had a be-
ginning in time.1713 And this saying is also true, that “death is swallowed up in victory.”1714
It is apparent, then, that death cannot be unbegotten, seeing that it is shown to have both a
1706 John viii. 44.
1707 John viii. 44.
1708 The text is “sufficit tibi hæc sunt an habes et alia.” Routh proposes “sufficientia tibi hæc sunt,” etc.
1709 Routh would make it = You will come under the condemnation…you will have to bear: he suggests eris
ergo for ero ego, and feras for feram.
1710 Rom. v. 14.
1711 Rom. v. 14.
1712 Nec aliter nisi essent ingenita. Routh, however, would read esset for essent, making it = and that death
could be nothing else than unbegotten.
1713 Reading ex tempore for the corrupt exemplo re of the codex.
1714 1 Cor. xv. 54.
Chapter XXIX.
474
Chapter XXIX.