ANSW. Here, Sir, I suppose you intend only the same qualifications in kind; or a pro-
fession and visibility, in some degree, of the same sort of faith and repentance; meaning that
which is truly evangelical and saving. And understanding you in this sense, I am persuaded,
by all I can observe, that the generality of protestants are in the affirmative; not assenting
to a specific and essential difference, whatever circumstantial and gradual disparity they
may allow, between the two cases you mention.
Mr. Baxter, speaking of the judgment and practice of the christian fathers, tells us, that
faith (justifying faith, and not another kind of faith) was supposed to be in the parent, for
himself and his seed: because the condition or qualification of the infant is but this, that he
be the seed of a believer. And he thinks the generality of the reformed are in these sentiments.
He declares his own judgment in full concurrence herewith, and backs the same with a
variety of arguments, in his Five Disputations, and other writings. He observes, it seems
strange to him that any should imagine, a lower belief in the parent will help his child to a
title to baptism, than that which is necessary to his own, if he were unbaptized; because
mutual consent is necessary to mutual covenant, and the covenant must be mutual. No man
hath right to God’s part, that refuseth his own: they that have no right to remission of sins,
have no right given them by God to baptism. If God be not at all actually obliged in covenant
to any ungodly man, then he is not obliged to give him baptism: but God is not obliged so
to him. Most of our divines make the contrary doctrine Pelagianism, that God should be
obliged to man in a state of nature in such a covenant. If the parent’s title be questionable,
(says he,) the infant’s is so too; because the ground is the same: and it is from the parent
that the child must derive it; nor can any man give that which he hath not. We ought not
(says he) to baptize those persons, or their children, as theirs, who are visible members of
the kingdom of the devil, or that do not so much as profess their forsaking the devil’s king-
dom: but such are all that profess not a saving faith. If such are not visibly in the kingdom
of the devil, at least they are not visibly out of it. All that are duly baptized, are baptized into
Christ; therefore they are supposed to possess that faith by which men are united or ingrafted
into Christ: but that is only justifying faith. Tell me (says he) where any man was ever said
in Scripture to be united to Christ, without saving faith, or profession of it. In a word, Mr.
Baxter takes occasion to declare himself in this manner: If Mr. Blake exacts not a profession
of saving faith and repentance, I say he makes foul work in the church. And when such foul
work shall be voluntarily maintained, and the word of God abused for the defilement of the
church and ordinances of God, it is a greater scandal to the weak, and to the schismatics,
and a greater reproach to the church, and a sadder case to considerate men, than the too
common pollutions of others, which are merely through negligence, but not justified and
defended.
We are told by other impartial inquirers, that all the reformed do in their directories
and practices require professions, as well as promises, of parents bringing their children to
1891
Appendix. Mr. Foxcroft's letter.