Though Hilary was not its inventor, and was forced
by the large part played by Old Testament exegesis in the Arian
controversy to employ it, whether he would or not The
unhesitating use of the Theophanies of the Old Testament as direct
evidence for the divinity of Christ is noteworthy. Similar to the
usual proofs for the distinction of Persons within the Trinity, from
the alternate use of plural and singular, are the arguments in Tr.
in Ps. cxviii., Iod, 5, cxxvii. 4., yet it is certain that his hearty,
though not indiscriminate It is worth notice
that he makes no use of Origen’s mystical interpretation of the
Canticles. Silence in such a case is itself a criticism., acceptance of the
method led to its general adoption in the West. Tertullian and
Cyprian had made no great use of such speculations; Irenæus
probably had little influence. It was the introduction of
Origen’s thought to Latin Christendom by Hilary and his
contemporaries which set the fashion, and none of them can have had
such influence as Hilary himself. It is a strange irony of fate
that so deep and original a thinker should have exerted his most
permanent influence not through his own thoughts, but through this
dubious legacy which he handed on from Alexandria to Europe. Yet
within certain limits, it was a sound and, for that age, even a
scientific method; and Hilary might at least plead that he never
allowed the system to be his master, and that it was a means which
enabled him to derive from Scriptures which otherwise, to him, would be
unprofitable, some treasure of true and valuable instruction. It
never moulds his thoughts; at the most, he regards it as a useful
auxiliary. No praise can be too high for his wise and sober
marshalling not so much of texts as of the collective evidence of
Scripture concerning the relation of the Father and the Son in the
De Trinitate; and if his Christology be not equally convincing,
it is not the fault of his method, but of its application Compare such a
passage as Trin. x. 24 with his use of the proof-texts against
Arianism.. We cannot wonder that Hilary, who owed
his clear dogmatic convictions to a careful and independent study of
Scripture, should have wished to lead others to the same source of
knowledge. He couples it with the Eucharist as a second Table of
the Lord, a public means of grace, which needs, if it is to profit the
hearer, the same preparation of a pure heart and life Tr. in Ps.
cxxvii. 10.. Attention to the lessons read in
church is a primary duty, but private study of Scripture is enforced
with equal earnestness E.g. Tr. in
Ps. xci. 10, cxviii. Iod, 15, cxxxiv. 1, cxxxv.
1.. It must be
for all, as Hilary had found it for himself, a privilege as well as a
duty.