28. As we said above, so now we repeat, that the
divine generation must not be compared to the nature of men, nor the
Son considered to be part of God, nor the generation to imply any
passion whatever; God is not as man; for men beget passibly, having a
transitive nature, which waits for periods by reason of its weakness.
But with God this cannot be; for He is not composed of parts, but being
impassible and simple, He is impassibly and indivisibly Father of the
Son. This again is strongly evidenced and proved by divine Scripture.
For the Word of God is His Son, and the Son is the Father’s Word
and Wisdom; and Word and Wisdom is neither creature nor part of Him
whose Word He is, nor an offspring passibly begotten. Uniting then the
two titles, Scripture speaks of
‘Son,’ in order to herald the natural and true offspring of
His essence; and, on the other hand, that none may think of the
Offspring humanly, while signifying His essence, it also calls Him
Word, Wisdom, and Radiance; to teach us that the generation was
impassible, and eternal, and worthy of God. This
is a view familiar to the Fathers, viz. that in this consists our
Lord’s Sonship, that He is the Word, or as S. Augustine says,
Christum ideo Filium quia Verbum. Aug. Ep. 120. 11. Cf. de
Decr. §17. ‘If I speak of Wisdom, I speak of His
offspring;’ Theoph. ad Autolyc. i. 3. ‘The Word, the
genuine Son of Mind;’ Clem. Protrept. p. 58. Petavius
discusses this subject accurately with reference to the distinction
between Divine Generation and Divine Procession. de Trin. vii.
14.
What affection then, or what part of the Father is the Word and the
Wisdom and the Radiance? So much may be impressed even on these men of
folly; for as they asked women concerning God’s Son, so Orat. iii. 67. let them inquire of men concerning the Word,
and they will find that the word which they put forth is neither an
affection of them nor a part of their mind. But if such be the word of
men, who are passible and partitive, why speculate they about passions
and parts in the instance of the immaterial and indivisible God, that
under pretence of reverence Heretics have frequently assigned reverence as the cause of their
opposition to the Church; and if even Arius affected it, the plea may
be expected in any other. ‘O stultos et impios metus,’ says
S. Hilary, ‘et irreligiosam de Deo sollicitudinem.’ de
Trin. iv. 6. It was still more commonly professed in regard to the
Catholic doctrine of the Incarnation. Cf. Acta Archelai [Routh.
Rell. v. 169]. August. contr. Secund. 9, contr.
Faust. xi. 3. As the Manichees denied our Lord a body, so the
Apollinarians denied Him a rational soul, still under pretence of
reverence because, as they said, the soul was necessarily sinful.
Leontius makes this their main argument, ὁ νοῦς
ἁμαρτητικός
ἐστι. de Sect. iv.
p. 507. vid. also Greg. Naz. Ep. 101. ad Cledon. p. 89;
Athan. in Apoll. i. 2. 14. Epiph. Ancor. 79. 80. Athan.,
&c., call the Apollinarian doctrine Manichæan in consequence.
vid. in Apoll. ii. 8. 9. &c. Again, the Eranistes in
Theodoret, who advocates a similar doctrine, will not call our Lord
man. Eranist. ii. p. 83. Eutyches, on the other hand,
would call our Lord man, but refused to admit His human
nature, and still with the same profession. Leon. Ep. 21.
1 fin. ‘Forbid it,’ he says at Constantinople, ‘that
I should say that the Christ was of two natures, or should discuss the
nature, φυσιολογεῖν, of my God.’ Concil. t. 2. p. 157 [Act.
prima conc. Chalc. t. iv. 1001 ed. Col.] A modern argument for
Universal Restitution takes a like form; ‘Do not we shrink
from the notion of another’s being sentenced to eternal
punishment; and are we more merciful than God?’ vid. Matt. xvi. 22,
23. they may deny the
true and natural generation of the Son? Enough was said above to shew
that the offspring from God is not an affection; and now it has been
shewn in particular that the Word is not begotten according to
affection. The same may be said of Wisdom; God is not as man; nor must
they here think humanly of Him. For, whereas men are capable of wisdom,
God partakes in nothing, but is Himself the Father of His own Wisdom,
of which whoso partake are given the name of wise. And this Wisdom too
is not a passion, nor a part, but an Offspring proper to the Father.
Wherefore He is ever Father, nor is the character of Father
adventitious to God, lest He seem alterable; for if it is good that He
be Father, but has not ever been Father, then good has not ever been in
Him.