(3.) The Ecclesiastical Conservatives.
Something has already been said in more than one connection to explain
how it came to pass that the very provinces whose bishops made up the
large numerical majority at Nicæa, also furnished the numbers
which swelled the ranks of the Eusebians at Tyre, Antioch, and
Philippopolis. The actual men were, of course, in many cases Alexander
of Thessalonica had been at Nicæa, Dianius of Cæs. Capp. had
not. The two are typical of the better sort of
conservatives. changed in the course of years, but the sees
were the same, and there is ample evidence that the staunch Nicene
party were in a hopeless minority in Asia Minor For Asia
besides Marcellus we have only Diodorus of Tenedos, not at Nicæa,
but expelled soon after 330, p. 271; signs at Sardica, p. 147, banished
again p. 276, not in D.C.B.; for Syria the names p. 271, cf. p.
256. and but
little stronger in Syria. The indefiniteness of this mass of episcopal
opinion justifies the title ‘Conservative.’ In adopting it
freely, we must not forget, what the whole foregoing account has gone
to shew, that their conservatism was of the empirical or short-sighted
kind, prone to acquiesce in things as they are, hard to arouse to a
sense of a great crisis, reluctant to step out of its groove. If by
conservatism we mean action which really tends to preserve the vital
strength of an institution, then Athanasius and the leaders of
Nicæa were the only conservatives. But it is not an unknown thing
for vulgar conservatism to take alarm at the clear grasp of principles
and facts which alone can carry the State over a great crisis, and by
wrapping itself up in its prejudices to play into the hands of anarchy.
Common men do not easily rise to the level of mighty issues. Where
Demosthenes saw the crisis of his nation’s destiny, Æschines
saw materials for a personal impeachment of his rival. In the
anti-Nicene reaction the want of clearness of thought coincided with
the fatal readiness to magnify personal issues. Here was the
opportunity of the Arian leaders: a confused succession of personal
skirmishes, in which the mass of men saw no religious principle, nor
any combined purpose (Soc. i. 13, νυκτομαχίας
τε οὐδὲν
ἀπεῖχε τὰ
γινόμενα) was conducted
from headquarters with a fixed steady aim. But their machinations would
have been fruitless had the mass of the bishops been really in sympathy
with the council to which they were still by their own action
committed. ‘Arian hatred of the council would have been powerless
if it had not rested on a formidable mass of conservative discontent:
while the conservative discontent might have died away if the court had
not supplied it with the means of action’ (Gwatkin, p. 61. He
explains the policy of the court by the religious sympathies of Asia
Minor Always an
important factor in the stability of the Byzantine throne, see, on
Justinian, D.C.B. iii. 545a, sub fin. Newman, Arians,
Appendix v., brings no conclusive proof of strong Nicene feeling among
the masses of the laity in this region. But ‘the people’ in
Galatia, according to Basil, remained devoted to Marcellus. and its political importance, pp.
90–91.) But the authority of the council remained unchallenged
during the lifetime of Constantine, and no Arian raised his voice
against it. One doctrinal controversy there was, of subordinate
importance, but of a kind to rivet the conservatives to their attitude
of sullen reaction.