299
Historical Introduction.
(Hefele, History of the Councils, Vol. IV., p. 289.)
In accordance with the imperial command, but without the assent of the Pope, the
synod was opened on the 5th of May a.d. 553, in the Secretarium of the Cathedral Church
at Constantinople. Among those present were the Patriarchs, Eutychius of Constantinople,
who presided, Apollinaris of Alexandria, Domninus of Antioch, three bishops as represent-
atives of the Patriarch Eustochius of Jerusalem, and 145 other metropolitans and bishops,
of whom many came also in the place of absent colleagues.
(Bossuet, Def. Cleri Gall., Lib. vii., cap. xix. Abridged. Translation by Allies.)
The three chapters were the point in question; that is, respecting Theodore of
Mopsuestia, Theodoret’s writings against Cyril, and the letter of Ibas of Edessa to Maris the
Persian. They examined whether that letter had been approved in the Council of Chalcedon.
So much was admitted that it had been read there, and that Ibas, after anathematizing
Nestorius, had been received by the holy Council. Some contended that his person only
was spared; others that his letter also was approved. Thus inquiry was made at the fifth
Council how the writings on the Faith were wont to be approved in former Councils. The
Acts of the third and fourth Council, those which we have mentioned above respecting the
letter of St. Cyril and of St. Leo, were set forth. Then the holy Council declared: “It is plain,
from what has been recited, in what manner the holy Councils are wont to approve what is
brought before them. For great as was the dignity of those holy men who wrote the letters
recited, yet they did not approve their letters simply or without inquiry, nor without taking
cognizance that they were in all things agreeable to the exposition and doctrine of the holy
Fathers, with which they were compared.” But the Acts proved that this course was not
pursued in the case of the letter of Ibas; they inferred, therefore, most justly, that that letter
had not been approved. So, then, it is certain from the third and fourth Councils, the fifth
so declaring and understanding it, that letters approved by the Apostolic See, such as was
that of Cyril, or even proceeding from it, as that of Leo, were received by the holy Councils
not simply, nor without inquiry. The holy Fathers proceed to do what the Bishops at
Chalcedon would have done, had they undertaken the examination of Ibas’s letter. They
compare the letter with the Acts of Ephesus and Chalcedon. Which done, the holy Council
declared—“The comparison made proves, beyond a doubt, that the letter which Ibas is said
to have written is, in all respects, opposed to the definition of the right Faith, which the
Council of Chalcedon set forth.” All the Bishops cried out, “We all say this; the letter is
heretical.” Thus, therefore, is it proved by the fifth Council, that our holy Fathers in Ecu-
menical Councils pronounce the letters read, whether of Catholics or heretics, or even of
Roman Pontiffs, and that on matter of Faith, to be orthodox or heretical, according to the
same procedure, after legitimate cognizance, the truth being inquired into, and then cleared
up; and upon these premises judgment given.
Historical Introduction.
550
Historical Introduction.