54 ON THE TRINITY. [BOOK II.
and, I saw : but in those things which are shown to the eyes
through express corporeal forms, the common expression is not,
It appeared to me ; but, I saw. There may, therefore, be a
question raised respecting that fire, how it was seen ; whether
within in the spirit as it were outwardly, or really outwardly
before the eyes of the flesh. But of that dove, which is said to
have descended in a bodily form, no one ever doubted that it
was seen by the eyes. Nor, again, as we call the Son a Eock
(for it is written, "And that Eock was Christ " ^), can we so call
the Spirit a dove or fire. Tor that rock was a thing already
created, and after the mode of its action was called by the
name of Christ, whom it signified ; like the stone placed under
Jacob's head, and also anointed, which he took in order to
signify the Lord;^ or as Isaac was Christ, when he carried
the wood for the sacrifice of himself^ A particular significa-
tive action was added to those already existing things ; they
did not, as that dove and fire, suddenly come into being in
order simply so to signify. The dove and the fire, indeed,
seem to me more like that flame which appeared to Moses in
the bush,* or that pillar which the people followed in the
wilderness,^ or the thunders and lightnings which came
when the Law was given in the mount.^ For the corporeal
form of these things came into being for the very purpose,
that it might signify something, and then pass away.
Chap. vii.—A doubt raised about divine appearances.
12. The Holy Spirit, then, is also said to be sent, on account
of these corporeal forms which came into existence in time,
in order to signify and manifest Him, as He must needs be
manifested, to human senses ; yet He is not said to be less
than the Father, as the Son, because He was in the form of a
servant, is said to be ; because that form of a servant inhered
in the unity of the person of the Son, but those corporeal
forms appeared for a time, in order to showwhatwas necessary
to be shown, and then ceased to be. Why, then, is not the
Father also said to be sent, through those corporeal forms, the
fire of the bush, and the pillar of cloud or of fire, and the
lightnings in the mount, and whatever other things of the
1 1 Cor. X. 4. - Gen. xxviii. 18. ^ Gen. xxii. G.
* Ex. iii. 2.
•'•
Ex. xiii. 21, 22. ^ Ex. xix. IG.