9. A. Art is one thing, that which is Reading quod
super artes est.above art is another. Medical skill,
craftsmanship, and so on, are found in many persons; but to be always
without sin is a characteristic of the Divine power only. Therefore,
either give me an instance of those who were for ever without sin; or,
if you cannot find one, confess your impotence, lay aside bombast, and
do not mock the ears of fools with this being and possibility
of being of yours. For who will grant that a man can do what no man
was ever able to do? You have not learnt even the rudiments of logic.
For if a man is able, he is no longer unable. Either grant that some
one was able to do what you maintain was possible to be done; or if no
one has had this power, you must, though against your will, be held to
this position, that no one is able to effect what yet you profess to be
possible. That was the point at issue between the powerful logicians, That is,
Diodorous, surnamed Cronus, who lived at Alexandria in the reign of
Ptolemy Soter (b.c. 323–285). He was the
teacher of Philo. For his discussions On the Possible,
Zeller’s “Socrates and the Socratic Schools,”
Reichel’s translation, pp. 272, 273, and authorities there cited,
may be consulted.Diodorus and Died b.c. 207, aged 73. He was the first to base the
Stoic doctrine on something like systematic reasoning.Chrysippus, in their discussion of
possibility. Diodorus says that alone can possibly happen which is
either true or will be true. And whatever will be, that, he says, must
of necessity happen. But whatever will not be, that cannot possibly
happen. Chrysippus, however, says that things which will not be might
happen; for instance, this pearl might be broken, even though it never
will. They, therefore, who say that a man can be without sin if he
chooses, will not be able to prove the truth of the assertion, unless
they show that it will come to pass. But whereas the whole future is
uncertain, and especially such things as have never occurred, it is
clear that they say something will be which will not be. And
Ecclesiastes supports this decision: “All that shall be, has
already been in former ages.”