LETTER LXXXIV.
177
I have the book in my hand as it was pub-
lished twenty years ago. In numbers of
my works and especially in my commenta-
ries I have, as occasion has offered, mangled
this heathen school. And if my opponents
allege that I have done more than anyone
else to form a collection of Origen's books, I answer that I only wish I could have the
works of all theological writers that by
diligent study of them, I might make up for
the slowness of my own wits. I have made
a collection of his books, I admit ; but be-
cause I know everything that he has writ-
ten I do not follow his errors. I speak as a Christian to Christians : believe one who has
tried him. His doctrines are poisonous, they
are unknown to the Holy Scriptures, nay
more, they do them violence. I have read
Origen, I repeat, I have read him; and if it is
a crime to read him, I admit my guilt: indeed,
these Alexandrian writings have emptied my
purse. If you will believe me, I have never
been an Origenist: if you will not believe me, I have now ceased to be one. But if even this
fails to convince you, you will compel me in
self-defence to write against your favourite,
so that, if you will not believe me when I dis-
claim him, you will have to believe me \vlu-n I attack him. But I find readier credence
when I go wrong than when I shew amend-
ment. And this is not surprising, for my
would-be friends suppose me a fellow-dis-
ciple with them in the arcana of their sys-
tem. I am loath, they fancy, to profess
esoteric doctrines before persons who accord-
ing to them are brute-like and made of clay.
For it is an axiom with them that pearls
ought not to be lightly cast before swine, nor
that which is holy given to the dogs.' They
agree with David when he says: "Thy word have I hid in mine heart that I might not sin
against thee; "a and when in another place he
describes the righteous man as one " who
speaketh truth with his neighbour,"* that is with those who "are of the household of
faith." From these passages they con- clude that those of us who as yet are unin-
itiated ought to be told falsehoods, lest,
being still unweaned babes, we should be
choked by too solid food. Now that perjury
and lying enter into their mysteries and form
a bond between them appears most clearly
from the sixth book of Origen's Miscel-
lanies, * in which he harmonizes the Chris-
tian doctrine ' with the conceptions of Plato. 4. What must I do then ? deny that I am
of Origen's opinion ? They will not believe me. Swear that I am not ? They will laugh
* Ps.cxix. ii. 4 Gal. vi 10. 1 Matt. vii. 6. • Fs. xv. 2, 3 from memory.
• <TT<XUH<ITHS. lit. = ' tapestries.' See note on Loiter I.XX. $ 4. • The doctrine alluded to is probably that of the Trinity. 12
and say that I deal in lies. I will do the one
thing which they dread. I will bring forward
their sacred rites and mysteries, and will
expose the cunning whereby they delude
simple folk like myself. Perhaps, although
they refuse credence to my voice when I
deny, they may believe my pen when I ac- cuse. Of one thing they are particularly
apprehensive, and that is that their writings
may some day be taken as evidence against
their master. They are ready to make state- ments on oath and to disclaim them after-
wards with an oath as false as the first. When
asked for their signatures they use shifts and
seek excuses. One says : " I cannot con-
demn what no one else has condemned."
Another says : " No decision was arrived at
on the point by the Fathers." ' It is thus tKat they appeal to the judgment of the
world to put off the necessity of assenting to
a condemnation. Another says with yet more
assurance : " how am I to condemn men whom the council of Nicaea has left untouched ? For
the council which condemned Arius would
surely have condemned Origen too, had it
disapproved of his doctrines." They were bound in other words to cure all the diseases
of the church at once and with one remedy ;
and by parity of reasoning we must deny the
majesty of the Holy Ghost because nothing was said of his nature in that council. But the
question was of Arius, not of Origen ; of the
Son, not of the Holy Ghost. The bishops at
the council proclaimed their adherence to a
dogma which was at the time denied ; they
said nothing about a difficulty which no one
had raised. And yet they covertly struck at
Origen as the source of the Arian heresy :
for, in condemning those who deny the Son
to be of the substance of the Father, they
have condemned Origen as much as Arius.
On the ground taken by these persons we
have no right to condemn Valentine,11 or
Marcion,1 or the Cataphrygians,4 or Mani- chaeus, none of whom are named by the
council of Nicaea, and yet there is no doubt
that in time they were prior to it. But when
they find themselves pressed either to sub- scribe or to leave the Church, you may see
some strange twisting. They qualify their
words, they arrange them anew, they use
vague expressions ; so as, if possible, to hold
both our confession and that of our oppo-
nents, to be called indifferently heretics and Catholics. As if it were not in the same
spirit that the Delphian Apollo (or, as he is
sometimes called, Loxias) gave his oracles
1 /'. e. the Bishops present at Nicaea. * The founder of a Gnostic sect in the second century. He
taught first in Egypt and afterwards in Rome. » See note on Letter XLVIII. $ a.
4 The Montanists were so called because the headquarters of their sect were at Pcpuza a small village in Phrygia.