Dittrich finds in this epistle an evidence that Dionysius was not
fully convinced of the advisability of re-baptizing converts from
heretical bodies, that he wavered in fact between the Eastern and the
Roman practices, but I am unable to see that the epistle implies
anything of the kind. It is not that he doubts the necessity of
re-baptism in ordinary cases,—he is not discussing that subject
at all,—the question is, does long communion itself take the
place of baptism; does not a man, unwittingly baptized, gain through
such communion the grace from the Spirit which is ordinarily conveyed
in baptism, and might not the rite of baptism at so late a date be an
insult to the Spirit, who might have been working through the sacrament
of the eucharist during all these years? It is this question which
Dionysius desires to have Xystus assist him in answering—a
question which has nothing to do, in Dionysius’ mind, with the
validity or non-validity of heretical baptism, for it will be noticed
that he does not base his refusal to baptize the man upon the fact that
he has already been baptized, partially, or imperfectly, or in any
other way, but solely upon the fact that he has for so long been
partaking of the eucharist.