not searchers of hearts. But the argument is about the phrase as Philip put it to the eunuch’s
own conscience, which was or ought to be a searcher of his heart.
And by the way I must observe, that Mr. W. would have done well, if he was able, to
have reconciled these repugnant things, taken notice of in my book; “That with the heart
man believeth to righteousness,” and that if men believe with the heart that God raised
Christ from the dead, they shall be saved; agreeable to Rom. x. 9, 10. And yet that men may
believe this with their heart, yea, and with all their heart, and still not believe to righteousness,
nor ever be saved. So likewise that “whoever shall confess that Jesus is the Son of God, God
dwelleth in him, and he in God;” as in 1 John iv. 15. And that ” whosoever believeth that
Jesus is the Christ, is born of God,” 1 John v. 1. And yet, that a man may believe this very
thing ” with all his heart, and confess it with his mouth;” and this in the language of the
same apostles and primitive ministers; and still not be born of God, nor have a spark of grace
in him.
It may also be worthy to be considered, whether it be reasonable to suppose, that the
faith which a man must profess, in order to being in the visible kingdom of Christ, and not
in the visible kingdom of the devil, must not be some other sort of faith than that which the
devil has: that seeing the very design of a public profession of religion is to declare on which
side we are, whether on Christ’s, or on the devil’s, no other faith is required to be professed,
than such as Satan himself has, and such as is not at all inconsistent with being a willing,
cursed servant and slave of the devil, and enemy to Christ; as Mr. W. says all unsanctified
men are.
Mr. W. in his reply to my argument from the epistles, (p. 55.) speaks of it as an unac-
countable thing, that I should represent as if according to the principles of my opposites,
the primitive Christians were not admitted under any such notion of their being really godly
persons, or with any respect to such a character: 419 and yet in his discourse on the same
head, he abundantly insists, that it was not real holiness, but only federal holiness, which
was the qualification to which the apostles had respect in admitting them; expressly, from
time to time, distinguishing federal holiness from real. In p. 56. e. and 57. a. “It makes it
evident (says he) that this manner of treating churches and bodies of men, and such expres-
sions used to them and of them, are to be understood in no other sense, than to signify
federal holiness.”—So in p. 60 he affirms the same thing, once and again, distinguishing
federal holiness from real. He says, they formed no positive judgment of their real piety.—And
knew nothing at all about them, but only that they were federally holy. And again, “They
did not make a positive judgment, that these persons were really godly; and the high char-
acters they gave them, and the hopes they expressed concerning them, could be understood
419 So in p. 132. c. he exclaims against me thus; ” After all this, to repeat it again and again, that these persons
have no visibility to reason of real, saintship, &c. I think, gives better ground to retort Mr. Edwards’s words
1998
SECTION IX. Mr. W. is inconsistent with himself.