When we were together in
council, dearest brethren, we read the letter which you addressed to us
respecting those who are thought to be baptized by heretics and
schismatics, whether, when they come to the one true Catholic Church,
they ought to be baptized. Wherein, although ye yourselves also
hold the Catholic rule in its truth and fixedness, yet since, out of
our mutual affection, ye have thought good to consult us, we deliver
not our sentence as though new but, by a kindred harmony, we unite with
you in that long since settled by our predecessors, and observed by us;
thinking, namely, and holding for certain, that no one can be baptized
without the Church, in that there is one Baptism appointed in the holy
Church, and it is written, the Lord himself speaking, “They have
forsaken me, the Fountain of living water, and hewed them out broken
cisterns that can hold no water.” Again, holy Scripture
admonishes us, and says, “Keep thee from the strange water, and
drink not from a fountain of strange water.” The water then
must first be cleansed and sanctified by the priest, that it may be
able, by Baptism therein, to wash away the sins of the baptized, for
the Lord says by the prophet Ezekiel, “Then will I sprinkle clean
water upon you, and ye shall be cleansed from all your filthiness, and
from all your idols will I cleanse you; a new heart also will I give
you, and a new spirit will I put within you.” But how can
he cleanse and sanctify the water, who is himself unclean, and with
whom the Spirit is not? whereas the Lord says in Numbers, “And
whatsoever the unclean person toucheth shall be unclean.”
Or how can he that baptizeth give remission of sins to another, who
cannot himself free himself from his own sins, out of the Church?