where “the generated essence itself,” as he says, “and the appellation of ‘Son,’ make such a
relation of words appropriate”? If, on the other hand, he should say that these appellations
signify relationship, he will necessarily appear in the character of an advocate of the com-
munity of essence, and as maintaining the fact that by affinity of names is signified also the
connection of subjects: and this he often does in his composition without being aware of
it578. For, by the arguments wherewith he endeavours to destroy the truth, he is often himself
unwittingly drawn into an advocacy of the very doctrines against which he is contending.
Some such thing the history tells us concerning Saul, that once, when moved with wrath
against the prophets, he was overcome by grace, and was found as one of the inspired, (the
Spirit of prophecy willing, as I suppose, to instruct the apostate by means of himself,) whence
the surprising nature of the event became a proverb in his after life, as the history records
such an expression by way of wonder, “Is Saul also among the prophets579?”
At what point, then, does Eunomius assent to the truth? When he says that the Lord
Himself, “being the Son of the living God, not being ashamed of His birth from the Virgin,
often named Himself, in His own sayings, ‘the Son of Man’”? For this phrase we also allege
for proof of the community of essence, because the name of “Son” shows the community
of nature to be equal in both cases. For as He is called the Son of Man by reason of the
kindred of His flesh to her of whom He was born, so also He is conceived, surely, as the Son
of God, by reason of the connection of His essence with that from which He has His existence,
and this argument is the greatest weapon of the truth. For nothing so clearly points to Him
Who is the “mediator between God and man580” (as the great Apostle called Him), as the
name of “Son,” equally applicable to either nature, Divine or Human. For the same Person
is Son of God, and was made, in the Incarnation, Son of Man, that, by His communion with
each, He might link together by Himself what were divided by nature. Now if, in becoming
Son of Man, he were without participation in human nature, it would be logical to say that
neither does He share in the Divine essence, though He is Son of God. But if the whole
compound nature of man was in Him (for He was “in all points tempted like as we are, yet
without sin”581), it is surely necessary to believe that every property of the transcendent es-
sence is also in Him, as the Word “Son” claims for Him both alike—the Human in the man,
but in the God the Divine.
If then the appellations, as Eunomius says, indicate relationship, and the existence of
relationship is observed in the things, not in the mere sound of the words (and by things I
mean the things conceived in themselves, if it be not over-bold thus to speak of the Son and
578 Oehler’s punctuation is here slightly altered.
579 1 Sam. xix. 24.
580 1 Tim. ii. 5.
581 Heb. iv. 15.
280
He thus shows the oneness of the Eternal Son with the Father the identity…