For a further reason they cannot justly take
offence in this point. When the persons whom you, Eusebius and his
fellows, dispatched with your letters, I mean Macarius the Presbyter,
and Martyrius and Hesychius the Deacons, arrived here, and found that
they were unable to withstand the arguments of the Presbyters who came
from Athanasius, but were confuted and exposed on all sides, they then
requested me to call a Council together, and to write to Alexandria to
the Bishop Athanasius, and also to Eusebius and his fellows, in order
that a just judgment might be given in presence of all parties. And
they undertook in that case to prove all the charges which had been
brought against Athanasius. For Martyrius and Hesychius had been
publicly refuted by us, and the Presbyters of the Bishop Athanasius had
withstood them with great confidence: indeed, if one must tell the
truth, Martyrius and his fellows had been utterly overthrown; and this
it was that led them to desire that a Council might be held. Now
supposing that they had not desired a Council, but that I had been the
person to propose it, in discouragement of those who had written to me,
and for the sake of our brethren who complain that they have suffered
injustice; even in that case the proposal would have been reasonable
and just, for it is agreeable to ecclesiastical practice, and well
pleasing to God. But when those persons, whom you, Eusebius and his
fellows, considered to be trustworthy, when even they wished me to call
the brethren together, it was inconsistent in the parties invited to
take offence, when they ought rather to have shewn all readiness to be
present. These considerations shew that the display of anger in the
offended persons is petulant, and the refusal of those who decline to
meet the Council is unbecoming, and has a suspicious appearance. Does
any one find fault, if he sees that done by another, which he would
allow if done by himself? If, as you write, each council has an
irreversible force, and he who has given judgment on a matter is
dishonoured, if his sentence is examined by others; consider, dearly
beloved, who are they that dishonour councils? who are setting aside
the decisions of former judges? Not to inquire at present into every
individual case, lest I should appear to press too heavily on certain
parties, the last instance that has occurred, and which every one who
hears it must shudder at, will be sufficient in proof of the others
which I omit.