But perhaps a man would be more easily led into the true view by
personal illustrations; so let us leave this looking backwards and
forwards and this twisting of false premisses τὸ
κατηγκυλωμένον
τῆς τῶν
συφισμάτων
πλοκῆς. See c.
38, note 7. The false premisses in the syllogisms have
been—
1. Father (partly) means
᾽Αγέννητος
Things which mean the same in
part, mean the same in all (false premiss).
∴ Father means ᾽Αγέννητος
(false).
2. Father means ᾽Αγέννητος
(false).
᾽Αγέννητος
does not mean ‘having a Son.’
∴ Father does not mean ‘having a Son’
(false)., and
discuss the matter in a less learned and more popular way. Your father,
Eunomius, was certainly a human being; but the same person was also the
author of your being. Did you, then, ever use in his case too this
clever quibble which you have employed; so that your own
‘father,’ when once he receives the true definition of his
being, can no longer mean, because of being a ‘man,’ any
relationship to yourself; ‘for he must be one of two things,
either a man, or Eunomius’ father?’—Well, then, you
must not use the names of intimate relationship otherwise than in
accordance with that intimate meaning. Yet, though you would indict for
libel any one who contemptuously scoffed against yourself, by means of
such an alteration of meanings, are you not afraid to scoff against
God; and are you safe when you laugh at these mysteries of our faith?
As ‘your father’ indicates relationship to yourself, and at
the same time humanity is not excluded by that term, and as no one in
his sober senses instead of styling him who begat you ‘your
father’ would render his description by the word
‘man,’ or, reversely, if asked for his genus and answering
‘man,’ would assert that that answer prevented him from
being your father; so in the contemplation of the Almighty a reverent
mind would not deny that by the title of Father is meant that He is
without generation, as well as that in another meaning it represents
His relationship to the Son. Nevertheless Eunomius, in open contempt of
truth, does assert that the title cannot mean the ‘having
begotten a son’ any longer, when once the word has conveyed to us
the idea of ‘never having been generated.’