23. The judges said: If we consider that the light existed before the estate of the creatures
was introduced, and that there was no object in an opposite position which might generate
shadow, it must follow that the light was then diffused everywhere, and that all places were
illuminated with its effulgence, as has been shown by what you have stated just now; and
as we perceive that the true explanation is given in that, we assign the palm to the affirmations
of Archelaus. For if the universe is clearly divided, as if some wall had been drawn through
the centre of it, and if on the one side the light dwells, and on the other side the darkness,
it is yet to be understood that this darkness has been brought accidentally about through
the shadow generated in consequence of the objects which have been set up in the world;
and hence again we must ask who it is that has built this wall between the two divisions,
provided you indeed admit the existence of such a construction, O Manichæus. But if we
have to take account of this matter on the supposition that no such wall has been built, then
again it comes to be understood that the universe forms but one locality, without any excep-
tion, and is placed under one power; and if so, then the darkness can in no way have an
ungenerated nature. Archelaus said: Let him also explain the following subject with a view
to what has been propounded. If God is seated in His kingdom, and if the wicked one in
like manner is seated in his kingdom, who can have constructed the wall between them?
For no object can divide two substances except one that is greater than either,1643 even as
it is said1644 in the book of Genesis, that “God divided the light from the darkness.”1645
Consequently the constructor of this wall must also be some one of a capacity like that: for
the wall marks the boundaries of these two parties, just as among people who dwell in the
rural parts a stone is usually taken to mark off the portion of each several party; which custom,
however, would afford a better apprehension of the case were we to take the division to refer
specially to the marking out of an inheritance falling to brothers. But for the present I have
not to speak of matters like these, however essential they may appear. For what we are in
quest of is an answer to the question, Who can have constructed the wall required for the
designation of the limits of the kingdom of each of these twain? No answer has been given.
Let not this perfidious fellow hesitate, but let him now acknowledge that the substance of
his duality has been reduced again to a unity. Let him mention any one who can have con-
structed that middle wall. What could the one of these two parties have been engaged in
when the other was building? Was he asleep? or was he ignorant of the fact? or was he unable
to withstand the attempt? or was he bought over with a price? Tell us what he was about,
or tell us who in all the universe was the person that raised the construction. I address my
appeal to you, O judges, whom God has sent to us with the fullest plenitude of intelligence;
1643 Reading utriusque majus. The Codex Casinensis has utrunque majus.
1644 The text is dicit, for which dicitur may be adopted.
1645 Gen. i. 4.
Chapter XXIII.
459
Chapter XXIII.