Having observed these things, let us now try whether this notion of the Liberty of Will
consisting in Indifference and equilibrium, and the Will’s self-determination in such a state,
be not absurd and inconsistent.
And here I would lay down this as an axiom of undoubted truth; that every free act is
done in a state of freedom, and not only after. such a state, If an act of the Will be an act
wherein the soul is free, it must be exerted in a state of freedom, and in the time of freedom.
It will not suffice, that the act immediately follows a state of Liberty; but Liberty must yet
continue, and co-exist with the act; the soul remaining in possession of Liberty. Because
that is the notion of a free act of the soul, even an act wherein the soul uses or exercises
Liberty. But if the soul is not, in the very time of the act, in possession of Liberty, it cannot
at that time be in the use of it.
Now the question is, whether ever the soul of man puts forth an act of Will, while it yet
remains in a state of Liberty, viz. as implying a state of Indifference; or whether the soul
ever exerts an act of preference, while at that very time the Will is in a perfect equilibrium,
not inclining on way more than another. The very putting of the question is sufficient to
show the absurdity of the affirmative answer: for how ridiculous would it be for nay body
to insist, that the soul chooses one thing before another, when at the very same instant it is
perfectly indifferent with respect to each! This is the same thing as to say, the soul prefers
one thing to another, at the very same time that it has no preference.—Choice and preference
can no more be in a state of Indifference, than motion can be in a state of rest, or than the
preponderation of the scale of a balance can be in a state of equilibrium. Motion may be the
next moment after rest; but cannot co-exist with it, in any, even the least, part of it. So choice
may be immediately after a state of Indifference, but cannot co-exist with it: even the very
beginning of it is not in a state of Indifference. And therefore, if this be Liberty, no act of
the Will, in any degree, is ever performed in a state of Liberty, or in the time of Liberty.
Volition and Liberty are so far from agreeing together, and being essential on to another,
that they are contrary one to another, and one excludes and destroys the other, as much as
motion and rest, light and darkness, or life and death. So that the Will acts not at all, does
not so much as begin to act, in the time of such Liberty: freedom has ceased to be,, at the
first moment of action; and therefore Liberty cannot reach the action, to affect, or qualify
it, or give it a denomination, any more than if it had ceased to be twenty years before the
action began. The moment that Liberty ceases to be, it ceases to be a qualification of any
thing. If light and darkness succeed one another instantaneously, light qualifies nothing
after it is gone out, to make any thing lightsome or bright, at the first moment of perfect
darkness, any more than months or years after. Life denominates nothing vital, at the first
moment of perfect death. So freedom, if it consists in or implies Indifference, can denominate
nothing free, at the first moment of preference or preponderation. Therefore it is manifest,
that no Liberty which the soul is possessed of , or ever uses, in any of its acts of volition,
570
SECTION VII. Concerning the notion of Liberty of Will, consisting in Indifference.…