Chapter XII.—The Bishops in Jerusalem.
1. At this time Narcissus1530 was the bishop of the church at Jerusalem, and he is celeb-
rated by many to this day. He was the fifteenth in succession from the siege of the Jews under
Adrian. We have shown that from that time first the church in Jerusalem was composed of
Gentiles, after those of the circumcision, and that Marcus was the first Gentile bishop that
presided over them.1531
1530 The date of Narcissus’ accession to the see of Jerusalem is not known to us. The Chron. affords us no
assistance; for although it connects him among other bishops with the first (Armen.) or third (Jerome) year of
Severus, it does not pretend to give the date of accession, and in one place says expressly that the dates of the
Jerusalem bishops are not known (non potuimus discernere tempora singulorum). But from chap. 22 we learn
that he was already bishop in the tenth year of Commodus (189 a.d.); from chap. 23, that he was one of those
that presided at a Palestinian council, called in the time of Bishop Victor, of Rome, to discuss the paschal question
(see chap. 23, §2); from Bk. VI. chap. 8, that he was alive at the time of the persecution of Severus (202 sq.); and
from the fragment of one of Alexander’s epistles given in Bk. VI. chap. 11, that he was still alive in his 116th
year, sometime after 212 a.d. (see Bk. VI. chap. 11, note 1). Epiphanius (Hær. LXVI. 20) reports that he lived
until the reign of Alexander Severus (222 a.d.), and this in itself would not be impossible; for the epistle of Alex-
ander referred to might have been written as late as 222. But Epiphanius is a writer of no authority; and the fact
is, that in connection with Origen’s visit in Palestine, in 216 (see Bk. VI. chap. 19), Alexander is mentioned as
bishop of Jerusalem; and Narcissus is not referred to. We must, therefore, conclude that Narcissus was dead
before 216. We learn from Bk. VI. chap. 9 that Narcissus had the reputation of being a great miracle-worker,
and he was a man of such great piety and sanctity as to excite the hatred of a number of evil-doers, who conspired
against him to blacken his character. In consequence of this he left Jerusalem, and disappeared entirely from
the haunts of men, so that it became necessary to appoint another bishop in his place. Afterward, his slanderers
having suffered the curses imprecated upon themselves in their oaths against him, Narcissus returned, and was
again made bishop, and was given an assistant, Alexander (see Bk. VI. chaps. 10 and 11). A late tradition makes
Narcissus a martyr (see Nicephorus, H. E. IV. 19), but there is no authority for the report.
1531 Upon the so-called bishops of Jerusalem down to the destruction of the city under Hadrian, see Bk. IV.
chap. 5. Upon the destruction of Jerusalem under Hadrian, and the founding of the Gentile Church in Ælia
Capitolina, and upon Marcus the first Gentile bishop, see Bk. IV. chap. 6. The list given here by Eusebius purports
to contain fifteen names, Marcus being the sixteenth, and Narcissus being the thirtieth; but only thirteen names
are given. In the Chron., however, and in Epiphanius (Hær. LXVI. 20) the list is complete, a second Maximus
and a Valentinus being inserted, as 26th and 27th, between Capito and Valens. The omission here is undoubtedly
due simply to the mistake of some scribe. The Chron. puts the accession of Cassianus into the 23d year of Ant-
oninus Pius (160 a.d.), and the accession of the second Maximus into the sixth year of Commodus (185 a.d.),
but it is said in the Chron. itself that the dates of the various bishops are not known, and hence no reliance can
be placed upon these figures. Epiphanius puts the accession of the first Gaius into the tenth year of Antoninus
Pius, which is thirteen years earlier than the date of the Chron. for the fourth bishop preceding. He also puts the
death of the second Gaius in the eighth year of Marcus Aurelius (168 a.d.) and the death of the second Maximus
The Bishops in Jerusalem.
531
The Bishops in Jerusalem.