331
On “Not Three Gods.”
To Ablabius.
————————————
Ye that are strong with all might in the inner man ought by rights to carry on the struggle
against the enemies of the truth, and not to shrink from the task, that we fathers may be
gladdened by the noble toil of our sons; for this is the prompting of the law of nature: but
as you turn your ranks, and send against us the assaults of those darts which are hurled by
the opponents of the truth, and demand that their “hot burning coals”1298 and their shafts
sharpened by knowledge falsely so called should be quenched with the shield of faith by us
old men, we accept your command, and make ourselves an example of obedience1299, in
order that you may yourself give us the just requital on like commands, Ablabius, noble
soldier of Christ, if we should ever summon you to such a contest.
In truth, the question you propound to us is no small one, nor such that but small harm
will follow if it meets with insufficient treatment. For by the force of the question, we are at
first sight compelled to accept one or other of two erroneous opinions, and either to say
“there are three Gods,” which is unlawful, or not to acknowledge the Godhead of the Son
and the Holy Spirit, which is impious and absurd.
The argument which you state is something like this:—Peter, James, and John, being
in one human nature, are called three men: and there is no absurdity in describing those
who are united in nature, if they are more than one, by the plural number of the name derived
from their nature. If, then, in the above case, custom admits this, and no one forbids us to
speak of those who are two as two, or those who are more than two as three, how is it that
in the case of our statements of the mysteries of the Faith, though confessing the Three
Persons, and acknowledging no difference of nature between them, we are in some sense
at variance with our confession, when we say that the Godhead of the Father and of the Son
and of the Holy Ghost is one, and yet forbid men to say “there are three Gods”? The question
is, as I said, very difficult to deal with: yet, if we should be able to find anything that may
give support to the uncertainty of our mind, so that it may no longer totter and waver in
this monstrous dilemma, it would be well: on the other hand, even if our reasoning be found
unequal to the problem, we must keep for ever, firm and unmoved, the tradition which we
received by succession from the fathers, and seek from the Lord the reason which is the
advocate of our faith: and if this be found by any of those endowed with grace, we must give
thanks to Him who bestowed the grace; but if not, we shall none the less, on those points
which have been determined, hold our faith unchangeably.
1298 Ps. cxx. 3; the phrase is rendered in A.V. by “coals of juniper,” in the Vulg. by “carbonibus desolatoriis.”
1299 Reading, with Oehler, εὐπειθείας
On 'Not Three Gods.'
615
On 'Not Three Gods.'