attempt to make the whole world depend on a Divine power is absurd, when it is made by
these men, who deny to the individualities in it a birth from the fiat of the Divine Will and
refer the several origins of beings to encounters that come of evil, as though there could
never have existed such a thing as a human life, unless a vice had struck, as it were, its
leading note. If the beginning is like that, a sequel will most certainly be set in motion in
456
accordance with that beginning. None would dare to maintain that what is fair can come
out of what is foul, any more than from good can come its opposite. We expect fruit in ac-
cordance with the nature of the seed. Therefore this blind movement of chance is to rule
the whole of life, and no Providence is any more to pervade the world.
Nay, even the forecasting by our calculations will be quite useless; virtue will lose its
value; and to turn from evil will not be worth the while. Everything will be entirely under
the control of the driver, Chance; and our lives will differ not at all from vessels devoid of
ballast, and will drift on waves of unaccountable circumstances, now to this, now to that
incident of good or of evil. The treasures of virtue will never be found in those who owe
their constitution to causes quite contrary to virtue. If God really superintends our life, then,
confessedly, evil cannot begin it. But if we do owe our birth to evil, then we must go on living
in complete uniformity with it. Thereby it will be shown that it is folly to talk about the
“houses of correction” which await us after this life is ended, and the “just recompenses,”
and all the other things there asserted, and believed in too, that tend to the suppression of
vice: for how can a man, owing, as he does, his birth to evil, be outside its pale? How can
he, whose very nature has its rise in a vice, as they assert, possess any deliberate impulse
towards a life of virtue? Take any single one of the brute creation; it does not attempt to
speak like a human being, but in using the natural kind of utterance sucked in, as it were,
with its mother’s milk1880, it deems it no loss to be deprived of articulate speech. Just in the
same way those who believe that a vice was the origin and the cause of their being alive will
never bring themselves to have a longing after virtue, because it will be a thing quite foreign
to their nature. But, as a fact1881, they who by reflecting have cleansed the vision of their
soul do all of them desire and strive after a life of virtue. Therefore it is by that fact clearly
proved that vice is not prior in time to the act of beginning to live, and that our nature did
not thence derive its source, but that the all-disposing wisdom of God was the Cause of it:
in short, that the soul issues on the stage of life in the manner which is pleasing to its Creator,
and then (but not before), by virtue of its power of willing, is free to choose that which is to
its mind, and so, whatever it may wish to be, becomes that very thing. We may understand
this truth by the example of the eyes. To see is their natural state; but to fail to see results to
them either from choice or from disease. This unnatural state may supervene instead of the
1880 συντρόφῳ
1881 ἀλλὰ μὴν introduces a fact into the argument (cf. καὶ μὴν); Lat. “verum enimvero.”
849
On the Soul and the Resurrection.