Chapter 1.—1. Let us not be considered troublesome to our readers, if we discuss the
same question often and from different points of view. For although the Holy Catholic
Church throughout all nations be fortified by the authority of primitive custom and of a
plenary Council against those arguments which throw some darkness over the question
about baptism, whether it can be the same among heretics and schismatics that it is in the
Catholic Church, yet, since a different opinion has at one time been entertained in the unity
of the Church itself, by men who are in no wise to be despised, and especially by Cyprian,
whose authority men endeavor to use against us who are far removed from his charity, we
are therefore compelled to make use of the opportunity of examining and considering all
that we find on this subject in his Council and letters, in order, as it were, to handle at some
considerable length this same question, and to show how it has more truly been the decision
of the whole body of the Catholic Church, that heretics or schismatics, who have received
baptism already in the body from which they came, should be admitted with it into the
communion of the Catholic Church, being corrected in their error and rooted and grounded
in the faith, that, so far as concerns the sacrament of baptism, there should not be an addition
of something that was wanting, but a turning to profit of what was in them. And the holy
Cyprian indeed, now that the corruptible body no longer presseth down the soul, nor the
earthly tabernacle presseth down the mind that museth upon many things,1759 sees with
greater clearness that truth to which his charity made him deserving to attain. May he
therefore help us by his prayers, while we labor in the mortality of the flesh as in a darksome
cloud, that if the Lord so grant it, we may imitate so far as we can the good that was in him.
But if he thought otherwise than right on any point, and persuaded certain of his brethren
and colleagues to entertain his views in a matter which he now sees clearly through the
revelation of Him whom he loved, let us, who are far inferior to his merits, yet following,
as our weakness will allow, the authority of the Catholic Church of which he was himself a
conspicuous and most noble member, strive our utmost against heretics and schismatics,
seeing that they, being cut off from the unity which he maintained, and barren of the love
with which he was fruitful, and fallen away from the humility in which he stood, are dis-
avowed and condemned the more by him, in proportion as he knows that they wish to
search out his writings for purposes of treachery, and are unwilling to imitate what he did
for the maintainance of peace,—like those who, calling themselves Nazarene Christians,
and circumcising the foreskin of their flesh after the fashion of the Jews, being heretics by
birth in that error from which Peter, when straying from the truth, was called by Paul1760
persist in the same to the present day. As therefore they have remained in their perversity
cut off from the body of the Church, while Peter has been crowned in the primacy of the
1759 Wisd. ix. 15.
1760 Gal. ii. 11.
Chapter 1
919
Chapter 1