15. The judges said: We need not inquire as to the manner in which that primitive
commerce took place until we have first seen it proved that there are two natural principles.
For when once it is made clear that there are two unbegotten natures, then others of your
averments may also gain our assent, even although something in them may not seem to fit
in very readily with what is credible. For as the power of pronouncing judgment has been
committed to us, we shall declare what may make itself clear to our mind. We may, however,
also grant to Archelaus the liberty of speaking to these statements of yours, so that, by
comparing what is said by each of you, we may be able to give our decision in accordance
with the truth. Archelaus said: Notwithstanding, the adversary’s intent is replete with gross
audacity and blasphemy. Manes said: Hear, O judges, what he has said of the adversary.1581
He admits, then, that there are two objects. Archelaus said: It seems to me that this man is
full of madness rather than of prudence, who would stir up a controversy with me to-day
because I chance to speak of the adversary. But this objection of yours may be removed with
few words, notwithstanding that you have supposed from this expression of mine that I
shall allow that there are these two natures.1582 You have come forward with a most extra-
vagant1583 doctrine; for neither of the assertions made by you holds good. For it is quite
possible that one who is an adversary, not by nature, but by determination, may be made a
friend, and cease to be an adversary; and thus, when the one of us has come to acquiesce
with the other, we twain shall appear to be, as it were, one and the same object. This account
also indicates that rational creatures have been entrusted with free-will,1584 in virtue of
which they also admit of conversions. And consequently there cannot be two unbegotten
natures.1585 What do you say, then? Are these two natures inconvertible? or are they con-
vertible? or is one of them converted? Manes, however, held back, because he did not find
a suitable reply; for he was pondering the conclusion which might be drawn from either of
two answers which he might make, turning the matter over thus in his thoughts: If I say
that they are converted, he will meet me with that statement which is recorded in the Gospel
about the trees;1586 but if I say that they are not convertible, he will necessarily ask me to
explain the condition and cause of their intermingling. In the meantime, after a little delay,
1581 The text is “quid dixerit adversarii;” some propose “quod” or “quia dixerit,” etc.
1582 The manuscript reading is, “tam si quidem ex hoc arbitratus est se affirmaturum.” For this it is proposed
to read, as in the translation, “tametsi quidem ex hoc arbitratus es me affirmaturum.”
1583 The text gives ingentem. Routh suggests inscientem, stupid.
1584 [Vol. iii. 301–302. See Coleridge (on Donne), English Divines, vol. i. p. 87.]
1585 Adopting the proposed reading, “et ideo duæ, ingenitæ naturæ esse non possunt.” The text omits the
duæ, however; and in that case the sense would be simply, And consequently there cannot be unbegotten natures;
or perhaps, And so they (the creatures) cannot be of an unbegotten nature.
1586 [Matt. vii. 15–20.]
Chapter XV.
443
Chapter XV.