Protestant
Controversialists, as well as others, have curious ways of stating
historical events without any regard to the facts of the case. A
notable instance of this is found in Dr. Salmon’s
Infallibility of the Church (p. 426 of the 2d Edition) where we
are told that “the only one of the great controversies in which
the Pope really did his part in teaching Christians what to believe was
the Eutychian controversy. Leo the Great, instead of waiting, as
Popes usually do, till the question was settled, published his
sentiments at the beginning, and his letter to Flavian was adopted by
the Council of Chalcedon. This is what would have always happened
if God had really made the Pope the guide to the Church. But this
case is quite exceptional, resulting from the accident that Leo was a
good theologian, besides being a man of great vigour of
character. No similar influence was exercised either by his
predecessors or successors.” This sentence is not pleasant
reading, for it is an awe-inspiring display of one of two things,
neither of which should be in the author of such a book. We need
only remind the reader that Celestine had condemned Nestorius and his
teaching before the Council of Ephesus; that Honorius had written
letters defining the question with regard to the will or wills of the
Incarnate Son before the III. Council of Constantinople (which
excommunicated him as a heretic for these very letters); that Pope
Vigilius condemned the “Three Chapters” before the II.
Council of Constantinople; and that Gregory II. condemned the
iconoclastic heresy before the Seventh Synod, if the letters attributed
to him be genuine (which is not quite certain, as will be shewn in its
proper place). Thus the only two great questions not decided, one
way or another, by the See of Rome before the meeting of a General
Council were Arianism and Macedonianism, and some have held (though
mistakenly as is generally thought) that Arius was condemned by a synod
held at Rome before that of Nice.