Holy Spirit should be understood to be separated also from baptism."1550 But if this is the
case, then when any one has received baptism in the Catholic Church, it remains so long in
him as he himself remains in the Church, which is not so. For it is not restored to him when
he returns, just because he did not lose it when he seceded. But as the disaffected sons have
not the Holy Spirit in the same manner as the beloved sons, and yet they have baptism; so
heretics also have not the Church as Catholics have, and yet they have baptism. "For the
Holy Spirit of discipline will flee deceit,"1551 and yet baptism will not flee from it. And so,
as baptism can continue in one from whom the Holy Spirit withdraws Himself, so can
baptism continue where the Church is not. But if "the laying on of hands" were not "applied
to one coming from heresy,"1552 he would be as it were judged to be wholly blameless; but
for the uniting of love, which is the greatest gift of the Holy Spirit, without which any other
holy thing that there may be in a man is profitless to his salvation, hands are laid on heretics
when they are brought to a knowledge of the truth.1553
1550 Cypr. Ep. lxxiv. 4.
1551 Wisd. i. 5.
1552 Cypr. Ep. lxxiv. 5.
1553 Cyprian, in the laying on of hands, appears to refer to confirmation, but Augustin interprets it of the
restoration of penitents. Cp. III. 16, 21.
853
Chapter 23